American Underdog – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

American Underdog

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

movie2021

68%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

Kurt Warner goes from grocery store stockboy to NFL Hall of Famer in this faith-filled, feel-good sports biopic that plays all the hits.

7.1/10

75%

98%

→

American Underdog

movie

PG, 2021

68%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

Kurt Warner goes from grocery store stockboy to NFL Hall of Famer in this faith-filled, feel-good sports biopic that plays all the hits.

7.1

75%

Jump to

Also rated on

7.1/10

75%

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

American Underdog is exactly what it says on the tin: a wholesome, faith-filled sports biopic that follows the formula to the letter. It's not going to win points for creativity or surprise anyone who's seen Rudy, but it doesn't need to.

The true story is genuinely inspiring, the family relationships are portrayed beautifully, and it models perseverance and humility in a way that resonates with kids. That 98% audience score isn't lying - people love this movie even if critics found it predictable.

The Christian themes are prominent enough that some families might find it too preachy, while others will appreciate the positive faith representation. Either way, it's safe, wholesome content that actually delivers on the inspiration front.

Is it a cinematic masterpiece? No. Will your sports-loving 12-year-old find it motivating? Probably. Will you mind watching it with them? Not at all - it's perfectly pleasant, which in the world of family-friendly content is actually a win.

Age Fit

Best for ages 10-17 who enjoy sports or inspirational stories. The faith-forward messaging and straightforward storytelling works well for tweens and teens. Adults who like feel-good sports movies will enjoy it too, but it's not sophisticated enough to be must-see cinema.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Uplifting true story centered on perseverance, faith, family, and kindness. Kurt Warner's journey models humility, dedication, and treating others with respect. The relationship with his wife Brenda and her children emphasizes commitment and love. Positive emotional tone throughout with strong moral values and no cynicism.

Imaginative

Standard sports biopic formula with minimal creative risk. Follows predictable underdog narrative beats without much visual or storytelling innovation. Based on real events so limited room for imaginative storytelling. Doesn't particularly inspire creative thinking or exploration beyond 'work hard and believe in yourself.'

Safe

Common Sense Media rates it for age 10+. PG rating means minimal content concerns. Some intense football scenes and brief references to Brenda's difficult past (abusive relationship, tragic loss of parents) but handled sensitively without graphic detail. Strong faith themes present but not preachy. No surprise violence, sexual content, or inappropriate language.

Enriching

Genuinely inspiring story about resilience, pursuing dreams despite obstacles, and the importance of family support. Teaches perseverance, humility, and faith. However, it's fairly straightforward inspiration without deep complexity or nuance. The 98% audience score on RT shows it resonates emotionally. Offers good discussion points about handling failure and believing in yourself.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Genuinely inspiring true story that shows kids (and adults) that persistence and character matter more than natural talent
Strong family values and positive relationship modeling - Kurt's commitment to Brenda and her kids is heartwarming
98% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes means it connects emotionally even if critics found it formulaic
Great conversation starter about handling rejection, staying humble in success, and supporting your partner's dreams
Clean, wholesome content that families can actually watch together without awkward remote-grabbing moments

⚠

What to Watch For

Heavy Christian faith themes throughout - if that's not your family's vibe, it might feel preachy
Brief references to domestic abuse and a tragic accident in Brenda's backstory (handled sensitively but worth noting for sensitive kids)
It's pretty predictable if you've seen any sports movie ever - you know exactly where this is going
Some intense football hits and game scenes that might be too much for younger or sensitive viewers

Conversation Starters

"Kurt got told 'no' so many times. When have you felt like giving up on something? What kept you going?"
"What do you think was harder for Kurt - stocking shelves when he wanted to play football, or staying humble after he became famous?"
"Brenda had to trust Kurt's dream even when it seemed impossible. How do you support your friends' goals even when they seem far-fetched?"
"Kurt's faith was really important to him. What values or beliefs help you when things get tough?"

Stills

On These Lists

All Lists

10 Football Movies to Consider

by John Perritt · 10 picks

John Perritt's football movie picks from his Family Movie Night newsletter (johnperritt.substack.com), from Rudy and Remember the Titans to American Underdog. Several are based on true stories, and a few are for older kids, so check the content first.

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Related Guides

Channing Tatum: Is the “Sparkella” Dad Actually for Kids?

Navigating the actor's range from toddler-approved books and animated hits to the R-rated roles you shouldn’t watch with them.

Writing about American Underdog? Put this WISE score on your site