Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Look, let's be honest: After Earth is not good. The critics savaged it, audiences shrugged, and even M. Night Shyamalan fans pretend it doesn't exist. The premise—Jaden Smith trekking across a hostile future Earth while Will Smith lies in a crashed ship giving instructions—sounds decent on paper, but the execution is painfully dull.

The pacing drags, the dialogue is stiff, and the performances feel wooden (even from usually-charismatic Will Smith). The father-son dynamic is the only element with potential emotional weight, but it's undermined by heavy-handed messaging and a script that tells rather than shows. Kids might stick with it for the sci-fi action, but there are dozens of better options in this genre.

The WISE score reflects reality: it's reasonably safe for tweens, has some wholesome themes about courage, but lacks imagination and entertainment value. If your kid is really into post-apocalyptic survival stories, maybe—but honestly, you'd be better off with almost any other sci-fi adventure from the past decade. This one's a skip unless you're a completist or really curious about cinematic misfires.

Age Fit

Best for ages 11-14 who are into sci-fi survival stories and can handle intense peril and heavy themes. Older teens and adults will likely find it tedious and poorly made—this isn't a family movie night winner for broad appeal.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

55

Father-son relationship is central, showing themes of courage and overcoming fear. However, the emotional tone is heavy and serious throughout, with a dying father and a traumatized son dealing with PTSD from his sister's death. The pacing is slow and the atmosphere is tense rather than uplifting. Models perseverance but lacks warmth or joy.

Imaginative

45

The premise of Earth 1,000 years after humans left has potential, but execution is derivative and uninspired. The world-building is generic sci-fi with little originality—evolved predators, hostile terrain, standard survival tropes. Doesn't invite curiosity or creative thinking; it's a straightforward survival trek with predictable beats. The 'ghosting' concept (suppressing fear to become invisible to predators) is the only mildly interesting idea.

Safe

65

Rated for ages 12+ by Common Sense Media. Contains sci-fi violence, peril, and creatures attacking humans, but no gore or graphic content. A character's death (sister) is referenced and traumatic for the protagonist. The overall tone is intense and scary in parts with life-threatening situations throughout. No sexual content, minimal language. The violence is action-oriented rather than gratuitous, making it reasonably safe for tweens and up, though younger kids might find it frightening.

Enriching

40

Attempts to explore themes of facing fear, father-son relationships, and coming-of-age under pressure. However, the execution is heavy-handed and preachy. The dialogue is wooden, character development is thin, and the philosophical elements feel forced. Limited skill-building or meaningful takeaways beyond 'fear is a choice' platitudes. The entertainment value is severely compromised by poor pacing, stiff performances, and a plodding narrative.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Father-son relationship at the core could resonate if your kid is working through similar dynamics
Survival story shows perseverance and facing fears head-on, even when terrified
Sci-fi setting with futuristic Earth might appeal to kids interested in post-apocalyptic scenarios
No inappropriate content for tweens—violence is sci-fi action without gore

⚠

What to Watch For

This movie is genuinely boring—slow pacing, wooden acting, and a plodding story that even kids might tap out of
Heavy themes of death and trauma (protagonist's sister was killed, he has PTSD) create a somber tone throughout
Intense peril and scary creatures might frighten younger or sensitive viewers
The 11% Rotten Tomatoes score isn't a fluke—this is widely considered a bad movie, so manage expectations

Conversation Starters

"Kitai had to face his biggest fear alone—what would you do if you were in his situation?"
"The movie talks about 'fear is a choice'—do you think that's true, or is fear sometimes automatic?"
"How do you think Kitai felt about his dad before vs. after their crash? Did their relationship change?"
"If Earth was abandoned for 1,000 years, what do you think would happen to all our cities and technology?"

Stills

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Related Guides

Jaden Smith: The 'Philosopher-King' Your Kid Probably Follows

From his luxury fashion pivot to his Skid Row activism, here’s the real take on Jaden’s music, influence, and that famous parenting style.

The Fresh Prince’s Family Picks: A Parent's Guide to Will Smith Movies

From 'Aladdin' to 'The Pursuit of Happyness,' learn which Will Smith classics are best for kids and which are better saved for after bedtime.

12 Best Will Smith Family Movies Ranked by Age Group

From Shark Tale to Men in Black, here are the best Will Smith movies for kids. We've ranked them by age so you know what's safe for family movie night.

The Last Sunrise: YA Romance Meets an R-Rating

This Mallorca-set romance based on Anna Todd's bestseller packs an R-rating for nudity and some risky medical rebellion—here's the real take.

Writing about After Earth? Put this WISE score on your site