Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This isn't a lazy cash-in. Hope Larson actually did the work to make L'Engle's weird, wonderful world feel modern and visceral.
If your kid is 'bored' by the 1962 original, this is the version that will actually get them to care about Meg Murry's journey. It’s safe, smart, and looks cool without trying too hard. It’s a top-tier choice for a kid who wants a 'real' story but prefers the graphic format.
Age Fit
Ideal for the 9-12 crowd. It’s sophisticated enough for middle schoolers but the visual format makes it accessible for a bright 4th grader who isn't ready for a 200-page block of text.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
It centers on a realistic, emotionally complex family dynamic and the power of love. The pacing is steady, and it avoids the chaotic 'brain rot' energy of modern visual media.
Imaginative
92
The visual interpretation of 'tessering' and the abstract depiction of the 'Black Thing' and the 2D world are creatively ambitious and spark genuine curiosity about physics and the cosmos.
Safe
98
Extremely safe. There is no profanity, graphic violence, or sexual content. The tension is psychological and thematic, appropriate for the target age group.
Enriching
90
It tackles heavy-duty themes like non-conformity, the battle between good and evil, and self-acceptance. It's an excellent entry point for reluctant readers to engage with classic literature.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
It’s a perfect bridge for kids who find the original book's text a bit dense or 'old-fashioned.'
Hope Larson’s blue-tinted artwork captures Meg’s awkward, 'bruised' emotional state in a way words sometimes can't.
Visually explains complex sci-fi concepts—like the fourth and fifth dimensions—making them way easier to digest.
Actually respects a kid's intelligence by keeping the sophisticated themes of the original novel intact.
⚠
What to Watch For
The 'IT' (a giant, pulsing brain) and the 'Black Thing' are abstractly creepy and might be a bit much for very sensitive 7-year-olds.
It's over 400 pages long; while it's a graphic novel, it’s still a significant 'read' that requires focus.
Conversation Starters
"Meg thinks her faults are her greatest strengths by the end—what's something you're 'bad' at that actually helps you sometimes?"
"If we could tesser anywhere in the universe right now, where would we go and why?"
"On the planet Camazotz, everyone has to do the exact same thing at the same time. Why does that feel so scary compared to our world?"
"Which of the three 'Mrs.' (Which, Who, Whatsit) would you want to hang out with?"
