A Tangle of Knots – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise
A Tangle of Knots
book2014Juvenile Fiction
91%
WISE Score
An orphan who bakes soul-reading cakes, a lost-luggage emporium, and a Talent Thief collide in a puzzle-box novel with actual recipes between chapters.
A Tangle of Knots
book
2014, Juvenile Fiction
91%
WISE Score
An orphan who bakes soul-reading cakes, a lost-luggage emporium, and a Talent Thief collide in a puzzle-box novel with actual recipes between chapters.
Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Lisa Graff's A Tangle of Knots earned its spot on the National Book Award longlist because it treats middle-grade readers like clever detectives. Set in a slightly askew world where fortunate people have a modest 'Talent,' the story follows eleven-year-old Cady, an orphan whose gift is baking the exact cake a person's soul needs before she even meets them. Her path winds toward a mysterious address housing a lost-luggage emporium, a family hunting for their own abilities, a boy who doesn't speak, and a man who literally inhales other people's Talents to steal them.
If you have a kid who loved the quirky superpower rules of Ingrid Law's Savvy or the interlocking mystery of Rebecca Stead's When You Reach Me, this sits right at that intersection. It takes a few chapters to get all the pieces on the board, so impatient readers might need a nudge past the setup. Once the gears catch, it's a warm, inventive read that usually ends with flour on your kitchen counter.
Age Fit
Sweet spot is 8 to 12 for independent readers who enjoy connecting plot threads, or 7+ as a family read-aloud (especially if you plan to bake the recipes together).
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92
Warm, empathetic middle-grade story centered on an eleven-year-old baker, found family, and how people's lives quietly connect. Handles grief and loss with gentleness rather than melodrama.
Imaginative
94
A quirky magical-realist world where everyday people have hyper-specific Talents (like baking the exact cake someone needs or spitting with pinpoint accuracy), structured as an interlocking puzzle box with real cake recipes between chapters.
Safe
95
Clean middle-grade fiction. Contains mild peril involving a 'Talent Thief' and backstory about an accident that left one character grieving and another unable to speak, but zero graphic content or shock value.
Enriching
91
A National Book Award finalist that rewards close reading. The multi-POV structure asks kids to hold several story threads in their head at once and piece together how fate and coincidence link the cast.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Puzzle-box storytelling that respects a kid's brain. Told across multiple viewpoints that slowly click together like a literary Rube Goldberg machine, rewarding kids who pay attention to small details.
A fresh spin on magic where powers aren't about shooting fireballs. Characters have hyper-specific, mundane 'Talents' — Cady can intuitively bake the exact cake a stranger needs, while others are brilliant at tying knots or rolling luggage.
Real, bakeable cake recipes are printed right in the book between sections, turning a quiet reading habit into an excuse to destroy the kitchen together on a Saturday.
Emotional weight without misery. It deals with orphans, a character who stopped speaking after an accident, and a bitter antagonist stealing other people's gifts, all while keeping a warm, whimsical tone.
⚠
What to Watch For
The opening takes patience. Because the book introduces several seemingly unrelated characters in rotating chapters (Cady, a timid boy named Zane, an owner of a lost-luggage shop), kids who want an immediate, single-track action plot might bounce off the first fifty pages.
Themes of grief and parental loss run underneath the whimsy. Cady is an orphan, and another storyline involves a tragic accident and a grieving spouse, though it is handled gently.
Conversation Starters
"If we lived in this world, what super-specific, everyday 'Talent' do you think each person in our house would have?"
"At what point in the book did you start figuring out how the lost-luggage emporium and Cady's story were actually connected?"
"The Talent Thief steals other people's abilities because he feels shortchanged. Do you feel bad for him at all, or is he just a creep?"
"Which of Cady's cakes from the recipes in the book are we actually going to bake this weekend?"
Deep Dive
A mystery built out of coincidences and cake batter
Middle-grade fantasy often falls into the trap of bigger-is-better: chosen ones, world-ending prophecies, and magic systems that read like video game skill trees. A Tangle of Knots goes the opposite direction. In Lisa Graff's world, a Talent is usually tiny. One person can tie knots perfectly. Another can spit with sniper-level accuracy. Cady happens to bake cakes that match a person's deepest preferences on the first try.
The real hook here isn't the magic system; it's the architecture of the plot. Graff writes in rotating perspectives, introducing a cast of misfits whose lives appear separate until they all converge on a single building — the home of a sky-blue lost-luggage emporium. For a 9- or 10-year-old who is ready to graduate from straightforward chapter books into stories where the author hides clues in plain sight, watching these threads tighten is deeply satisfying.
How to use it well
Try it on audio or as a read-aloud if your kid stalls early. Because the first third of the book hops between several characters before their connection is obvious, a kid who struggles with working memory might lose track of who's who. Listening together builds the language comprehension and narrative-tracking muscles without letting the multi-POV setup become a wall.
Budget for butter. The book includes Cady's actual cake recipes between chapters (like Peanut Butter Cake and Pomegranate Rosewater Cake). They aren't throwaway props — they work, and baking one when you finish the book is the easiest win you'll get all month.
Pair it with nearby cousins. If this lands well, look at Natalie Lloyd's A Snicker of Magic, Kate DiCamillo's The Magician's Elephant, or Trenton Lee Stewart's The Mysterious Benedict Society for a slightly higher-stakes puzzle.