Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Ava Reid has written a 'dark academia' novel that actually has something to say about the darkness. It’s not just about wearing tweed and drinking tea in a library; it’s a sharp, necessary critique of how women are erased from history and literature.
It’s moody, atmospheric, and deeply satisfying for anyone who grew up on fairy tales but now wants to see them deconstructed. If your kid is into the 'academic rivals' trope but wants a story with actual meat on its bones, this is the one.
Age Fit
Best for 14 and up. It’s a YA/Adult crossover that requires some emotional maturity to handle the themes of systemic abuse and mental health struggles.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
52
It's a heavy, dark gothic novel. While it models resilience and intellectual integrity, it deals with systemic abuse and institutional trauma rather than 'wholesome' cooperation.
Imaginative
91
The world-building is top-tier. Ava Reid crafts a meta-narrative about a fictional epic within her own story, blending architecture, folklore, and a uniquely damp, eerie atmosphere.
Safe
62
It's a book, so no surprise jump scares, but the content is mature. It features themes of sexual assault (backstory), gaslighting, and the use of 'bitters' as a coping mechanism for trauma.
Enriching
88
It's a brilliant critique of the 'Great Man' theory in literature. It encourages readers to question who gets to tell history and how women's contributions are erased.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Gothic Atmosphere: If they love rainy libraries, crumbling estates, and secrets hidden in the floorboards, this is the current gold standard.
Literary Mystery: It’s a book about books—specifically how stories get stolen and who actually gets the credit.
Dark Academia Vibes: It nails that intense, intellectual-rivals-to-lovers energy that's massive on BookTok right now.
Real Stakes: The 'Fairy King' isn't a sparkly love interest; he's a looming, creepy threat that feels genuinely unsettling.
⚠
What to Watch For
Heavy Backstory: The protagonist deals with the aftermath of sexual assault and institutional gaslighting. It’s handled with care, but it’s the central pillar of her trauma.
Drug Use: Effy takes 'bitters'—essentially fantasy-world sedatives—to manage her visions and anxiety. It's a realistic look at self-medicating for mental health.
Academic Sexism: The way the male professors treat the female leads is infuriatingly realistic. It's a great discussion point but can be a frustrating read.
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think the college was so quick to believe a man's story over a woman's evidence?"
"If the Fairy King represents a real-world threat to Effy, what do you think he stands for?"
"Is Preston right that 'the truth matters more than the story,' even if the story helps people survive?"
"How does the setting of a crumbling house by the sea mirror what's happening to Effy's mental state?"