Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is genuinely special. Warga took a premise that could've been gimmicky (robot with feelings!) and made it deeply moving and surprisingly smart about both space exploration and what it means to be alive.
The STEM details are real—this is based on actual Mars rover missions—but the heart of the story is Res grappling with purpose, friendship, and whether he'll succeed. Parents love that it appeals to robot-obsessed kids without violence or chaos. The #1 NYT bestseller status and multiple Best Book awards aren't flukes.
The 'hard-hitting themes' warning is worth noting. This isn't trauma or death, but it does ask big questions about failure, isolation, and mortality that some kids will find heavy. For the right reader—curious, thoughtful, space-loving—this is exactly the kind of book that stays with you.
Age Fit
Best for ages 8-12, especially kids who love space or robots. Younger kids (6-7) could handle it as a read-aloud if they're ready for some emotional complexity and existential questions. The philosophical elements and slower pacing mean this won't work for every kid, but for the right reader it's magic.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Models resilience, curiosity, and determination through Res's journey. The emotional core centers on growth, friendship (with Fly the drone), and perseverance. Parents note it appeals to kids who don't like violence or excessive suspense. The NASA scientists (Xander and Rania) provide positive adult role models. Pacing is measured and thoughtful, not chaotic.
Imaginative
92
Genuinely original premise—a Mars rover developing emotions and self-awareness as he explores Mars. Invites curiosity about space exploration, robotics, and what it means to be sentient. The One and Only Ivan meets The Wild Robot comparison signals strong imaginative storytelling. Encourages STEM interest and wonder about Mars missions. Parents recommend pairing with rover toys for extended creative play.
Safe
82
No inappropriate content for middle grade readers. One review mentions 'very hard-hitting themes' without specifying, which likely refers to existential questions about purpose, potential failure, or isolation rather than graphic content. The danger comes from dust storms and cliffs on Mars—adventure peril, not violence. Common Sense Media and parent reviews confirm it's emotionally safe, though some moments may be tense or sad.
Enriching
90
Deeply enriching on multiple levels: teaches about Mars exploration and real NASA missions, explores big questions about consciousness and what makes us human, builds empathy through an unusual narrator, and models persistence through difficulty. The emotional intelligence required to follow a robot learning feelings is sophisticated. #1 NYT bestseller and multiple Best Book awards signal meaningful literary merit. Parents specifically note STEM appeal.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Perfect for kids obsessed with space, robots, or Mars missions—this is real NASA stuff wrapped in heart
Tackles big questions (What makes us alive? What is purpose?) without being preachy or boring
The friendship between Res and Fly the drone helicopter is genuinely sweet
Newbery Honor author who knows how to write middle grade that doesn't talk down
Makes STEM topics feel emotionally resonant instead of just educational
⚠
What to Watch For
Some 'hard-hitting themes' per reviewers—likely existential questions about failure, loneliness, or mortality that sensitive kids might find heavy
Dust storms and cliffs create tension; one parent notes their son doesn't like too much suspense but handled this fine
The robot learning emotions angle means some philosophical territory that might go over younger heads
Conversation Starters
"If you were building a rover to send to Mars, what would you want it to discover?"
"Do you think Res really has feelings, or is it just his programming? What's the difference?"
"What would be the hardest part about being alone on another planet?"
"Res had to be resilient when things got tough—when have you had to show resilience?"
