Is this comic appropriate for a middle schooler?

Most 11- or 12-year-olds should skip it. While it lacks explicit sexual content, the bodily harm Lua suffers—absorbing necrotic wounds, internal bleeding, and graphic lacerations—pairs with heavy psychological gaslighting that fits high schoolers much better.

How dark does Lua's revenge actually get?

It leans into aristocratic ruin rather than brutal torture. Think public exposure, breaking court standing, and systematically dismantling social power, backed by an intimidating prince, rather than slasher-movie violence.

Is this a physical book or a phone app comic?

Both. It originated as a vertical-scroll webtoon on digital platforms like Tappytoon and Pocket Comics, but physical Japanese tankōbon volumes exist from publisher Ichijinsha, with localized editions circulating in manga sections.

Are there predatory microtransactions attached to reading it online?

Digital webtoon storefronts rely on 'wait-until-free' timers alongside micro-purchases to unlock immediate chapters. If your teen reads it on an app, keep in-app billing locked down so they aren't tempted to burn real cash chasing the next cliffhanger.

With Vengeance, Sincerely, Your Broken Saintess – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

With Vengeance, Sincerely, Your Broken Saintess

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2023

50%

WISE Score

A healer who absorbs everyone's bleeding wounds gets framed by her best friend and decides payback beats martyrdom.

With Vengeance, Sincerely, Your Broken Saintess

book

2023

50%

WISE Score

A healer who absorbs everyone's bleeding wounds gets framed by her best friend and decides payback beats martyrdom.

Jump to

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. As an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns from qualifying purchases, so if you buy a book or game through one of our links, we may earn a commission. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

If your teen is reading this, they're knee-deep in the webtoon villainess craze. The premise is textbook melodrama: Lua heals people by taking their agony into her own body, only for her best friend and crush to steal the credit and cast her out as a pariah. Instead of crying in a corner, she teams up with a shady prince to tear them down.

It is not gentle reading. Between the bodily trauma of wound transference and the relentless spite between characters, it operates strictly on spicy drama fuel. It is fun trash for high schoolers who want revenge catharsis, but not something you hand to a sixth grader looking for a light magic school read.

Age Fit

Best for readers 14 and up. The emotional cruelty and bloody consequences of Lua's healing power make it too harsh for younger fantasy fans, but it hits the exact sweet spot for older teens who devour dramatic webtoons.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

The entire premise runs on bitter betrayal, public humiliation, and calculated retribution. Lua stops playing the self-sacrificing martyr and actively leans into villainy to ruin the people who abused her.

Imaginative

Plays heavily into the popular villainess webtoon mold, but gives it a visceral hook: healing magic requires absorbing the actual physical trauma and scars of the person being healed.

Safe

Includes heavy emotional gaslighting, body horror tied to transferring bloody wounds, and intense themes of ostracization. Fine for older teens, but jarring for middle schoolers expecting cozy fantasy.

Enriching

Pure popcorn revenge melodrama. It raises real questions about the cost of people-pleasing and self-sacrifice, but trades moral nuance for satisfying payback.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Flips the martyr script by taking a heroine who literally suffered for others and letting her drop the nice-girl routine entirely.
Genuinely satisfying pacing if your teen loves high-drama Korean and Japanese villainess webcomics.
Striking visual storytelling that contrasts saintly church aesthetics with visceral, blood-soaked fantasy politics.

⚠

What to Watch For

Visceral injury absorption: Healing someone means Lua takes on their broken bones, flesh wounds, and near-death trauma, which gets graphically rendered.
Heavy toxic relationships: The early chapters focus on severe betrayal, public defamation, and emotional abuse from her supposed best friend and romantic interest.

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Lua had to reach rock bottom before she stopped letting people walk all over her?"
"Is there a difference between standing up for yourself and dedicating your whole life to revenge?"
"Why are revenge and villainess comics so wildly popular right now?"

Deep Dive

The Allure of the Scorched-Earth Protagonist

The fantasy subgenre often labeled 'villainess' or 'otome revenge' has exploded across comic platforms like Tappytoon and Pocket Comics. With Vengeance, Sincerely, Your Broken Saintess strips away the typical video-game reincarnation premise and grounds the drama in an abusive hierarchy.

Lua isn't just underappreciated; she's physically chewed up by her environment. Her divine power only works if she takes the physical damage onto her own flesh. Watching her wake up from saving someone's life only to find her best friend engaged to her crush and framing her as evil is dialed straight to an eleven.

Where It Lands for Teens

For a 14- or 15-year-old reader, this kind of comic functions like a gothic soap opera. The writing isn't deep literature, but it touches on very real adolescent anxieties:

Being excluded or smeared by a friend group
Sacrificing your own well-being to make others happy
The fantasy of walking back into the room with zero urge to be liked

The danger isn't that a kid reading this will start plotting medieval revenge. The catch is simply that it treats vindictiveness as the only viable response to hurt feelings. If you want stories with complicated moral dilemmas, look to Megan Whalen Turner's The Thief series. If your kid just wants to watch bad people face dramatic consequences in full color, this delivers exactly that.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about With Vengeance, Sincerely, Your Broken Saintess? Put this WISE score on your site