Is there any heavy content regarding race in this book?

It addresses the experience of being a Black student in a predominantly white or different cultural environment, but it does so through the lens of Cecil's personal interactions and shyness rather than graphic or traumatic events. It's thoughtful and age-appropriate.

My kid isn't a 'reader'—will they like this?

Yes. Graphic novels like Timid are the ultimate bridge for reluctant readers. The visual storytelling helps with comprehension, and the pacing keeps them turning pages faster than a standard novel would.

What is the 'trouble' Cecil gets into?

Without spoiling too much, it involves a drawing he made that wasn't meant for everyone to see. It’s a great way to talk about why we keep some thoughts in our private journals and how things can be misinterpreted when they go public.

Timid – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Timid

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2024

91%

WISE Score

Cecil moves to Massachusetts and realizes that being the 'new kid' is a lot harder when your private sketchbook becomes public property.

Timid

book

2024

91%

WISE Score

Cecil moves to Massachusetts and realizes that being the 'new kid' is a lot harder when your private sketchbook becomes public property.

Jump to

Where to Read

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.

Screenwise Verdict

If your kid is currently living in the 'middle school is a battlefield' phase, Timid is a must-read. It’s a semi-autobiographical win that captures the specific, sweaty-palms feeling of being the new kid who just wants to disappear into his notebook.

It isn't just another 'shy kid' story; it’s a specific look at a Black boy’s experience moving from Florida to a Boston suburb, dealing with the cultural whiplash and the struggle to find his people. It’s smart, visually engaging, and handles the 'trouble at school' trope with more grace than most.

Age Fit

Perfect for the 8-12 crowd. It hits that sweet spot of middle-school transition energy where everything feels high-stakes but is still handled with a gentle touch.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

A grounded, emotionally resonant story about a kid finding his voice. It models healthy self-reflection and the difficult process of setting boundaries with 'friends' who aren't actually kind.

Imaginative

The protagonist is a comic artist, so the book leans into the creative process and how kids use art to process their internal worlds.

Safe

Standard middle-grade graphic novel territory. There is some peer unkindness and a plot point involving a drawing that causes trouble, but nothing that would shock a target reader.

Enriching

Excellent for developing empathy regarding social anxiety and the specific cultural friction of moving from Florida to the Northeast. It addresses the complexity of being a Black student in a new school environment without being didactic.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Graphic novel format makes it an easy win for reluctant readers or kids who already inhaled everything by Raina Telgemeier.
Authentic social anxiety representation that doesn't feel like a lecture; Cecil’s internal monologue about fitting in is painfully relatable.
Art within art provides a cool look at how a 7th grader uses drawing to cope with a massive life change like moving states.
Nuanced friendships that show the difference between people who are just around and people who actually have your back.

⚠

What to Watch For

The central conflict involves peer unkindness and a drawing that gets Cecil into trouble, which might sting for kids currently dealing with school drama.
There's some minor bullying and social exclusion as Cecil navigates the hierarchy of his new Massachusetts school.

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Cecil felt safer drawing his feelings than saying them out loud?"
"Have you ever had a friend who was 'kind of' mean? How did you handle that?"
"If you had to move to a totally different state tomorrow, what's the one thing you'd be most nervous about?"
"What happened when Cecil's drawing got passed around, and what could his classmates have done differently?"

Deep Dive

The 'New Kid' logic

We’ve seen a lot of middle-grade graphic novels tackle the 'new school' transition, but Timid stands out because it feels lived-in. Jonathan Todd is drawing from his own life here, and you can tell. The specific details of moving from the warmth of Florida to the colder, faster-paced environment near Boston add a layer of realism that generic 'moving' stories lack.

Cecil is a protagonist who actually feels like a 7th grader. He’s not a hero; he’s a kid who draws comics and is trying to figure out how to exist in a space where he doesn't know the rules yet. The way the book handles the 'art getting him in trouble' plot point is a great jumping-off point for talking about digital and physical privacy. In a world where every kid is one 'send' button away from a social disaster, seeing Cecil navigate the fallout of a drawing being passed around is a very relevant lesson in social consequences.

If your kid liked Jerry Craft’s New Kid or the Invisible Emmie series, this is the exact same frequency. It’s high-quality, high-empathy, and the kind of book a kid will actually finish in one sitting and then want to talk about.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Timid? Put this WISE score on your site