2007, Juvenile Fiction
WISE Score
An orange, round, toddler-sized guessing game that plays with expectations and ends with a classic Halloween twist.
Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
This is a staple for the October book rotation. It doesn't try to be high art or a deep moral fable. It's just a sturdy, bright, and slightly cheeky board book that lets toddlers feel smart because they 'know' it's a pumpkin even when the book says it isn't.
It's the kind of book you'll end up reading three times in a row because it's short enough to not be annoying. If you have a toddler who loves the 'No, it's not!' game, this will be a hit.
This is squarely for the 1-to-3-year-old crowd. It's designed for short attention spans and kids who are just starting to master object identification.
It's a gentle, seasonal guessing game for the youngest readers with zero snark or edge.
Encourages kids to look past the obvious and participate in a narrative riddle.
A board book for toddlers is about as safe as media gets. No surprises, no scares.
Reinforces basic concepts like color, shape, and negation for early language development.
For kids in the 18-to-36-month range, literacy isn't just about learning letters—it's about the language comprehension side of the Reading Rope. Books like This Is NOT a Pumpkin build literacy knowledge by teaching kids how stories work: there’s a setup, a recurring question, and a payoff.
When you read this, lean into the 'No!' factor. Toddlers are in a developmental stage where they love asserting their knowledge. By the third page, they'll be arguing with the book. That's exactly what you want. It's active engagement rather than passive listening.
Even with all the interactive apps available, there's something about the physical 'reveal' of a page-turn in a board book that an iPad doesn't quite replicate for a two-year-old. It's tactile, it's durable, and it's a low-stimulation way to get into the Halloween spirit without the 'spooky' elements that might cause nightmares.
If your kid has already moved on to more complex narratives like Room on the Broom, this will feel like a step back. But for the littlest ones who are just figuring out that a pumpkin with a face is actually a jack-o'-lantern, it's a perfect fit.
Get a personalized guide on any topic
