2026
WISE Score
A 12-year-old moves to a 'perfect' Vermont town and realizes the local witch in the woods isn't the only one hiding something.
Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
This looks like a solid addition to the 'spooky-lite' middle-grade shelf. It is set to release in 2026 and hits all the right notes for kids who want a mystery that feels a little more mature without crossing into actual horror.
The Vermont setting is a classic choice for a reason—it provides a great backdrop for a story about uncovering what lies beneath a 'perfect' surface. If your kid liked Small Spaces or Wait Till Helen Comes, this will likely be right up their alley.
This is squarely in the 9-12 middle-grade wheelhouse. It is perfect for kids who have outgrown early chapter books and want a story with more atmosphere and a slightly sharper edge.
Middle-grade fiction usually hits a sweet spot of emotional growth and mystery. The focus on a girl navigating a new town and finding an unconventional friend is classic, healthy territory.
Vermont woods, secret-filled towns, and a young witch living off the grid offer plenty of atmospheric world-building potential for the target age group.
As a 2026 middle-grade release, this is expected to stay within standard age-appropriate boundaries, though 'darker secrets' implies some suspense and tension.
Explores themes of skepticism, social outsiders, and the reality that 'perfect' surfaces usually hide something worth questioning.
There is something inherently satisfying about a story that peels back the wallpaper of a pristine suburb to show the rot underneath. The Witch at Bittersweet End leans into this with Olive, a 12-year-old who isn't buying what her new Vermont town is selling. It is a great setup for building critical thinking in readers—teaching them to look past the 'seemingly perfect' and ask questions.
The introduction of Tamsin, the young witch in the woods, suggests the book will explore the idea of the 'outsider.' In middle-grade fiction, witches are often used as metaphors for independence or being misunderstood. By making Tamsin a central figure with 'secrets of her own,' the author is likely setting up a story about the complexity of friendship. It is rarely as simple as 'good vs. evil,' which is exactly the kind of nuance 10-year-olds are starting to crave.
Vermont in fiction is almost its own character—all fall leaves, deep woods, and old secrets. For a kid who might be stuck in a city or a flat suburb, this kind of atmospheric writing provides a great escape. It is the kind of book that is best read under a blanket with a flashlight, even if it isn't 'scary' in the traditional sense. It's about the mood.
Get a personalized guide on any topic
