Is there any explicit sexual content or spice in this book?

No. The book is widely categorized as a clean YA romance. Physical intimacy is limited to kissing, with the story focusing entirely on emotional connection and teenage friendship.

Is this book appropriate for a 12-year-old?

Yes, provided they are ready to read about topics like parental divorce and marital infidelity. Content-wise, it is very accessible for mature middle schoolers.

How heavy do the family issues get?

The main characters deal with realistic teenage grief regarding broken homes and distant parents, but the tone never becomes hopeless. It is balanced out by light banter and high school events.

Where did this book originate?

It started as a viral story on Wattpad, where author Alex Light built a fanbase before refining the story for traditional publication with HarperCollins.

The Upside of Falling: A Fun and Flirty Teen Romance – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

The Upside of Falling: A Fun and Flirty Teen Romance

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book

78%

WISE Score

4.3

Amazon

A fake-dating pact between a guarded bookworm and a varsity football captain morphs into a clean, low-drama YA romance about family baggage and real trust.

The Upside of Falling: A Fun and Flirty Teen Romance

book

78%

WISE Score

4.3

Amazon

A fake-dating pact between a guarded bookworm and a varsity football captain morphs into a clean, low-drama YA romance about family baggage and real trust.

4.3

Jump to

Also rated on

4.3

View →

Where to Read

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.

Screenwise Verdict

If your teen is looking to step up from middle-grade novels into high school romance, The Upside of Falling hits a gentle sweet spot. Born on Wattpad, Alex Light's novel takes a classic fake-dating setup—an introverted girl pretending to date the varsity football captain to stop being teased—and turns it into something sweet, light, and almost entirely clean.

While the fake-dating plot follows a predictable track, the emotional undercurrents give it substance. Both main characters are dealing with messy family realities—one working through parental divorce, the other coping with abandonment. The story addresses these themes thoughtfully without letting the mood devolve into total gloom.

For parents worried about spicy content in modern YA fiction, this book is a low-stress option. Physical affection tops out at kissing, making it an easy pick for younger teens.

Age Fit

Best for ages 12 to 16. It handles high school romance and family drama in an accessible, clean way without explicit content.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Offers an emotionally healthy portrayal of two teenagers supporting each other through real family strain. It keeps romance clean and age-appropriate without explicit content or toxic dynamics.

Imaginative

Relies heavily on standard YA tropes like fake dating and the popular-jock-meets-quiet-girl archetype, though executed with breezy execution.

Safe

Zero spice, no explicit sex, no violence, and no shock content. Physical intimacy stays at light kissing.

Enriching

Explores emotional vulnerability, unpacking family trauma, and unlearning cynical attitudes about trust and love.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Zero-spice romance: Ideal for readers stepping out of middle-grade books who want high school relationship drama without explicit content.
Bite-sized emotional depth: Covers teenage issues like parental divorce and grief without becoming oppressive or overly dark.
Relatable tropes: Leverages classic fake-dating mechanics with fast pacing that keeps reluctant readers turning pages.

⚠

What to Watch For

Heavy family themes: Beneath the breezy banter, both main characters carry emotional scars from parental infidelity, abandonment, and marital breakdown.

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Becca felt pressured to lie about having a boyfriend in the first place?"
"Did Brett's reasons for agreeing to fake-date make sense, or was he overcomplicating his life?"
"How did Becca's dad walking out shape how she treats people now?"

Deep Dive

Wattpad Tropes Done Right

Alex Light originally built a massive audience on Wattpad, and The Upside of Falling keeps the breezy, fast-moving style that makes serialized fiction so magnetic for young readers. It deliberately leans into familiar tropes: the quiet girl who reads romance, the popular athlete with a secret heart of gold, and a mutual arrangement to pretend to date that predictably leads to actual feelings.

What sets this apart from typical internet-born fiction is its restraint. Where many trending BookTok and YA recommendations lean into explicit physical scenes, this stays decidedly PG.

Emotional Baggage Beneath the Polish

While the main hook is lighthearted banter, the narrative gives both protagonists grounded reasons for being guarded. Becca is still processing her father walking out on her family years earlier, leaving her cynical about relationship promises. Brett is quietly managing the pressure of keeping his family's picture-perfect exterior intact while his parents' marriage crumbles.

These dynamics make the fake-dating agreement feel less like a silly sitcom plot and more like two teenagers building a genuine safe space together. It gives parents a simple doorway to talk about how kids handle family stress and social expectations.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about The Upside of Falling: A Fun and Flirty Teen Romance? Put this WISE score on your site