Is this a religious book?

It features a boy saying his prayers, which acts as the catalyst for the scarecrow's change of heart. While it isn't a 'Sunday School' book, it treats the act of prayer with respect and uses it as a central plot point.

Is it too scary for a 3-year-old?

Not at all. The scarecrow is portrayed as whimsical and eventually helpful. There are no 'jump scares' or villains; it's a very safe, nocturnal fantasy.

Does it work well as a bedtime story?

Yes, it's actually ideal for bedtime. The pacing is rhythmic and the ending is very quiet and settling, which helps lower the energy before sleep.

How long is the book?

It's a standard 32-page picture book. You can read it in about 5 to 7 minutes, depending on how much time you spend looking at the art.

The Scarecrow's Dance – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

The Scarecrow's Dance

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2009Juvenile Fiction

92%

WISE Score

A restless scarecrow abandons his post for a moonlit dance until a young boy’s prayer reminds him why he belongs in the cornfield.

The Scarecrow's Dance

book

2009, Juvenile Fiction

92%

WISE Score

A restless scarecrow abandons his post for a moonlit dance until a young boy’s prayer reminds him why he belongs in the cornfield.

Jump to

Where to Read

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.

Screenwise Verdict

If you're looking for a fall picture book that isn't just another 'spooky' Halloween title, this is it. Jane Yolen is a legend for a reason, and she manages to make a scarecrow’s mid-life crisis feel both magical and deeply human.

The art is the real star here. It doesn't look like a cartoon; it looks like a series of paintings you'd want to frame. It’s the kind of book that encourages kids to slow down and actually look at the pages. It’s wholesome, beautiful, and a great addition to the October reading rotation.

Age Fit

This is a sweet spot for the 4-8 range. It’s simple enough for a preschooler to follow as a read-aloud, but the vocabulary and themes are sophisticated enough to keep a 2nd grader engaged.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

The story centers on themes of duty, humility, and the power of a child's prayer. It's a gentle, values-driven narrative without being overly saccharine.

Imaginative

The concept of a scarecrow coming to life to dance through the fields is a classic whimsical hook, elevated by the specific characterization of the scarecrow as 'fickle' and then 'humbled.'

Safe

100

This is a picture book intended for young children. There is no objectionable content; the 'magic' is benevolent and the resolution is peaceful.

Enriching

It offers a quiet lesson on responsibility and empathy, showing the impact of one's work on the community (in this case, the boy and his family's harvest).

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Jane Yolen’s prose is consistently top-tier, bringing a lyrical quality to what could otherwise be a simple seasonal story.
The illustrations by Bagram Ibatoulline are known for being lush and realistic, making the book feel like an instant heirloom.
It’s a perfect seasonal transition book for fall that focuses on the harvest and gratitude rather than just ghosts and goblins.
The message of finding purpose in one's work is handled with a light touch that kids can actually grasp.

⚠

What to Watch For

The 'coming to life' element is magical, but if you have a kid who is genuinely spooked by the idea of inanimate objects moving at night, you might want to pre-read.
The ending is quiet and contemplative rather than a high-energy payoff; it’s a wind-down book, not an adventure.

Conversation Starters

"Why did the scarecrow decide to go back to the field after hearing the boy's prayer?"
"If you were the scarecrow, what would you have done during your night of dancing?"
"The boy prayed for the corn. What are some things we are thankful for in our own lives?"
"Does the scarecrow have a 'job'? Why is his job important to the farm?"

Deep Dive

A Harvest Classic

The Scarecrow's Dance is a rare bird in the world of juvenile fiction. Published in 2009, it feels like it could have been written eighty years ago, yet it avoids the stuffiness of many 'classic' children's books. Jane Yolen, who has written everything from Owl Moon to The Devil's Arithmetic, brings her characteristic weight to this story. She doesn't talk down to kids; she assumes they can handle a bit of melancholy and a lot of beauty.

Bagram Ibatoulline’s illustrations provide a cinematic, golden-hour feel to the farm. The lighting in the paintings—the contrast between the dark field and the small light in the farmhouse window—creates a sense of atmosphere that most modern, digitally-illustrated books lack.

For parents who prioritize literacy as language comprehension, this is a goldmine. The vocabulary is rich, and the narrative structure relies on the reader understanding the scarecrow's internal change of heart. It’s a great example of how a simple plot can carry significant emotional depth. If your family enjoys books that feel grounded in nature and the seasons, this belongs on your shelf alongside Ox-Cart Man.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about The Scarecrow's Dance? Put this WISE score on your site