Is it too scary for a 10-year-old?

It depends on the 10-year-old. There aren't jump scares, but the atmosphere is heavy and the threat of violence is constant. The scenes in the opium dens can be unsettling because they show the physical and mental toll of addiction.

Do we need to have read the book first?

Not at all. The movie does a good job of establishing Sally's world and the mystery of her father's death on its own. However, if they like the movie, the book is a great next step.

Yes, the BBC also adapted the second book, The Shadow in the North, with the same cast. It’s worth tracking down if your family enjoys this one.

How historically accurate is it?

While the specific plot is fiction, the backdrop of Victorian London—including the financial laws affecting women and the prevalence of opium—is grounded in historical reality.

The Ruby in the Smoke – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

The Ruby in the Smoke

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

movie2006

72%

WISE Score

Billie Piper tackles Victorian mysteries, opium dens, and family secrets in this moody Philip Pullman adaptation.

The Ruby in the Smoke

movie

12, 2006

72%

WISE Score

Billie Piper tackles Victorian mysteries, opium dens, and family secrets in this moody Philip Pullman adaptation.

Jump to

Also rated on

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

If your kid is into Enola Holmes but wants something with a bit more Victorian grit and less fourth-wall breaking, this is a solid choice. It's a BBC production through and through, which means great acting and a slightly dusty, deliberate pace that rewards attention.

It doesn't have the high-octane energy of modern blockbusters, but Sally Lockhart is a fantastic character for kids to get to know. She’s smart, capable, and operates in a world that is constantly trying to underestimate her. Just be ready for the opium subplots—they aren't glorified, but they are a major part of the scenery.

Age Fit

This is a bullseye for 11- to 14-year-olds who enjoy historical mysteries or have already finished Pullman's His Dark Materials. It's likely too slow for younger kids and maybe a bit 'quaint' for older teens used to grittier true crime.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

While it features a capable and determined lead, the story is steeped in the grime of Victorian London, featuring opium dens, murder, and high-stakes betrayal.

Imaginative

Philip Pullman's world-building is excellent, creating a dense mystery that requires the viewer to piece together historical clues alongside the protagonist.

Safe

Contains depictions of opium addiction, threats of violence, and some moderately intense moments of peril. It is safe for the intended teen audience but too dark for younger kids.

Enriching

Offers a sharp look at Victorian social structures, the British Empire's role in the opium trade, and a rare-for-its-time female protagonist with agency in a male-dominated world.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Strong female lead in Sally Lockhart, who is financially literate, brave, and refuses to play the damsel in distress.
Pre-fame star power with early roles for Matt Smith and Hayley Atwell that are fun to spot for fans of their later work.
Historical immersion that doesn't sugarcoat the Victorian era, showing the dark side of London's shipping and trade history.
Pullman pedigree means the mystery is actually clever and respects the viewer's intelligence.

⚠

What to Watch For

The depiction of opium addiction and dens is central to the plot; it's treated with gravity but might be a lot for younger viewers.
The pacing is very much '2006 BBC TV movie'—it’s slower and more deliberate than a modern Netflix thriller like Enola Holmes.
Several characters die, including a man who dies of a heart attack following a confrontation and a drowning mentioned early on.

Conversation Starters

"Why was Sally's knowledge of business and accounting considered so unusual for a woman in the 1870s?"
"How did the opium trade impact the British Empire and the people living in London at the time?"
"Sally's father left her a cryptic message. If you had to leave a secret message, what kind of code would you use?"
"Do you think Sally was right to investigate her father's death herself, or was it too dangerous?"

Deep Dive

The Pullman Connection

Long before His Dark Materials became a massive HBO hit, Philip Pullman was known for the Sally Lockhart mysteries. The Ruby in the Smoke is the first of these, and while it lacks the talking polar bears and armored bears of his later work, it shares that same sense of a young person navigating a dangerous, adult-driven world of secrets.

A Snapshot of History

What makes this movie worth the watch today isn't just the mystery—it's the cast. You’ve got Billie Piper (fresh off Doctor Who) as Sally, a very young Matt Smith as Jim Taylor, and Hayley Atwell as Rosa Garland. Seeing them all together in a 2006 period piece is a treat for any family that follows British TV.

Critically, the film handles the Victorian setting with more realism than many 'cozy' mysteries. It dives into the consequences of the British East India Company's actions and the reality of the opium trade. It’s a great entry point for talking about the darker side of the 19th century without being gratuitous.

The Pacing Reality Check

Let's be real: this is a TV movie from two decades ago. The cinematography is functional rather than breathtaking, and the action sequences aren't going to blow anyone's mind. If your kid needs a jump-scare or an explosion every ten minutes to stay engaged, this isn't the one. But if they like a 'detective' vibe where the clues actually matter, it holds up remarkably well. It’s essentially a Victorian noir that respects its audience.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic