2015, Juvenile Fiction
WISE Score
Two best friends treat the 'popular girls' like a scientific study in this handwritten, doodle-filled field guide to surviving the middle school social jungle.
Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
If your kid is obsessing over the social hierarchy of the playground, this is the manual they need. It’s funny, visually dense, and actually has a heart under all the 'research' and doodles.
While it follows the 'notebook novel' trend, it feels more personal and character-driven than most. It’s a great pick for reluctant readers who need the visual breaks but still want a story with real emotional stakes.
Perfect for the 8-to-12 crowd. It hits that sweet spot for 4th and 5th graders who are starting to eye the social complexities of middle school with a mix of curiosity and terror.
The core of the story is a rock-solid friendship between two girls who are weird and proud of it, even when they're trying to be 'normal.' It handles the social hierarchy of middle school without being cynical.
The notebook-style format—handwritten fonts, colored pencil drawings, and 'scrapbooked' artifacts—is incredibly creative and encourages kids to document their own lives visually.
Extremely safe middle-grade territory. The 'danger' here is social embarrassment and minor friendship tiffs. No mature content to worry about.
It offers a great look at how social performance works and why trying to be someone else usually fails. It’s a stealthy lesson in self-acceptance.
The Popularity Papers arrived right as the 'handwritten notebook' genre was exploding, but it stands out because it isn't just about slapstick or bathroom humor. Amy Ignatow uses the format to explore the messy, earnest, and often hilarious inner lives of two girls who are terrified of being invisible in middle school.
Julie and Lydia aren't just generic protagonists; they have distinct personalities that come through in their 'handwriting' and their drawing styles. Julie is the more reserved, artistic one (she has two dads, which the book treats with refreshing normalcy), while Lydia is the impulsive one with the big ideas. Their 'social experiment'—trying to figure out what makes the popular girls tick so they can replicate it—is a perfect setup for a middle-grade plot.
What makes this work for parents is that it doesn't moralize. It lets the girls make social mistakes and feel the consequences. It’s a great alternative for kids who might find the Diary of a Wimpy Kid series a bit too cynical or the Dork Diaries series a bit too 'girly.' This series hits a grounded, realistic middle ground that feels like actual 10-year-old life.
Get a personalized guide on any topic
