2014, Juvenile Fiction
WISE Score
A magical dreidel refuses to spin for spoiled kids but works perfectly for a boy who actually understands the meaning of Hanukkah.
Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
If you're looking for a Hanukkah book that goes deeper than just 'here is a menorah,' this is the pick. It’s a classic 'heart over greed' fable that manages to be educational without feeling like a textbook.
It avoids the generic holiday fluff by grounding the story in a specific moral lesson. Plus, the inclusion of the game rules makes it a functional tool for family night, not just a one-off story.
Perfect for the 3–8 crowd. It's a great read-aloud for preschoolers and a manageable solo read for early elementary students.
It's a gentle, moral-driven holiday story that prioritizes spirit and gratitude over materialism and entitlement.
The 'magical' object trope is a classic, but the illustrations by D. Yael Bernhard add a vibrant, stylized layer that elevates the storytelling.
Entirely safe for all ages. No scary themes, violence, or mature content.
Beyond the moral lesson, it functions as a cultural primer, including an appendix on Hanukkah traditions and actual rules for the dreidel game.
Martha Simpson’s The Dreidel That Wouldn't Spin follows a familiar folk-tale structure: a magical object, a series of 'unworthy' characters who fail to unlock its power, and a humble protagonist who succeeds through pure intent. It’s a formula that works because kids inherently understand the fairness of it. In this case, the 'unworthy' characters are two spoiled children who see the beautiful golden dreidel as a trophy rather than a tradition.
What makes this book worth the shelf space is the secondary material. Many holiday books for kids stay at the surface level, but Simpson includes a useful appendix. For families who celebrate Hanukkah, it’s a nice refresher; for families who don't, it’s an accessible way to build cultural literacy. The explanation of the Hebrew letters (Nun, Gimel, Hei, Shin) and the mechanics of the game turn the reading session into an activity.
The illustrations by D. Yael Bernhard deserve a mention. They have a textured, almost mural-like quality that feels timeless. They don't look like modern, slick digital cartoons, which fits the 'wonders still occur' theme of the book perfectly. It’s the kind of book that feels like it could have been published forty years ago or yesterday, which is exactly what you want in a holiday staple.
Get a personalized guide on any topic
