Should I Share My Ice Cream? – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Should I Share My Ice Cream?

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2011

89%

WISE Score

4.9

Amazon

Gerald overthinks whether to share his ice cream in this charming early reader that nails the internal drama of toddler generosity.

Should I Share My Ice Cream?

book

2011

89%

WISE Score

4.9

Amazon

Gerald overthinks whether to share his ice cream in this charming early reader that nails the internal drama of toddler generosity.

4.9

Jump to

Also rated on

4.9

View →

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is Mo Willems doing what he does best—taking a tiny moment of childhood angst and turning it into something funny, relatable, and genuinely useful for kids learning to navigate friendship and fairness.

The Elephant & Piggie books are early reader gold because they don't talk down to kids. Gerald's overthinking is real (that ice cream is melting!), and the resolution feels earned rather than forced. The format practically begs kids to read it aloud with expression, which builds both reading skills and confidence.

It's not groundbreaking literature, but it doesn't need to be. It's a solid, sweet book that helps kids process the genuinely hard work of being generous when you really, really want that ice cream for yourself. The 4.9 Amazon rating tells you everything—parents and kids both love these books, and for good reason.

Age Fit

Ideal for ages 3-7, especially new readers who need confidence-building books. The vocabulary is simple, the sentences are short, and the emotional content is perfectly pitched for preschool/early elementary social-emotional development.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Gerald's internal struggle about sharing models real emotional processing kids experience. The friendship between Gerald and Piggie consistently shows care, consideration, and ultimately generosity without being preachy. The humor comes from genuine character traits rather than meanness or chaos.

Imaginative

Mo Willems' signature simple illustrations and speech-bubble format invite kids to perform and interpret the story themselves. The internal monologue structure is creative, though the premise itself is straightforward. Part of the Elephant & Piggie series known for encouraging readers to engage with character voices and emotions.

Safe

Zero concerning content. A book about whether to share ice cream is about as safe as media gets. No violence, no scary elements, no mature themes. The only 'conflict' is Gerald's adorable internal debate.

Enriching

Tackles the genuine developmental challenge of sharing vs. self-interest with nuance—Gerald wants to share but also really wants the ice cream. The early reader format builds confidence, and the emotional vocabulary (worry, generosity, friendship) is age-appropriate. Amazon rating of 4.9 suggests strong parent/educator approval.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Mo Willems gets the real tension kids feel between wanting to be generous and wanting to keep the good stuff
Speech-bubble format makes kids feel like confident readers even when they're just starting out
Gerald and Piggie's friendship is genuinely sweet without being saccharine—these characters have personality
Short enough that you can read it 47 times in one sitting without losing your mind
Part of a huge series, so if your kid loves it, you've got 24 more books ready to go

⚠

What to Watch For

Some kids might find Gerald's anxiety relatable in a good way; others might find it stressful—know your kid
The ice cream melts while Gerald deliberates, which could spark tears in literal-minded toddlers who hate when food is wasted

Conversation Starters

"Have you ever had something you really wanted to keep for yourself but also wanted to share? What did you do?"
"Why do you think Gerald took so long to decide? What was he worried about?"
"Do you think it's okay to not share sometimes? When?"
"If you were Piggie, how would you feel if Gerald didn't share?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic