Of Mice and Men

Of Mice and Men

book

1993, Politics & Social Sciences, Politics & Government

WISE
48%

WISE Score

4.6

Amazon

Steinbeck's Depression-era tragedy of friendship and broken dreams—important literature that's genuinely hard for modern teens to love.

Amazon4.6
Common Sense Media

Where to Read

Amazon
Amazon
Barnes & Noble
Barnes & Noble
Libby
Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Look, this is a legitimate American classic that deserves its place in the literary canon. Steinbeck's writing is brilliant, the themes are profound, and the moral questions it raises about friendship, mercy, and impossible dreams are worth wrestling with.

But let's be real: this book is a tough sell for modern teens. It's bleak. It's slow. Reddit is full of teachers watching their 8th and 9th graders fall asleep. The language is deeply problematic (though historically accurate), the ending is devastating, and there's no hope or redemption to soften the blow.

If your teen is assigned this for school, great—it's worth reading with teacher support and class discussion to unpack the layers. But as a recreational pick? Unless your kid is a serious reader who loves literary fiction and can handle tragedy, this probably isn't it. The WISE score reflects that tension: enriching and important, but not wholesome, not particularly safe for younger readers, and genuinely hard to engage with for kids raised on faster-paced media.

Age Fit

Best for high schoolers (14+) who can handle heavy themes and tragic endings, ideally in a classroom with guided discussion. The language, violence, and emotional weight make it too much for middle schoolers reading independently, and honestly, many 9th graders struggle to stay engaged with it.

WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
42

This is a bleak, tragic story that ends with George mercy-killing his best friend Lennie. The novella explores themes of loneliness, broken dreams, and the harsh realities of Depression-era migrant workers. While the friendship between George and Lennie is genuine and touching, the overall emotional arc is devastating. There's casual ableism in how characters treat Lennie, racial slurs directed at the character Crooks, and a deeply misogynistic portrayal of Curley's wife (who doesn't even get a name). The tone is heavy, dark, and emotionally punishing—not exactly modeling kindness or offering hope.

Imaginative
58

Steinbeck's prose is spare and effective, with vivid descriptions of the California landscape and the bunkhouse. The recurring dream of George and Lennie's farm becomes an almost mythic symbol of hope. However, this is literary realism at its most unforgiving—there's no fantasy, no creative problem-solving, no world-building beyond the dusty confines of 1930s ranch life. It invites analytical thinking and literary interpretation, but doesn't spark curiosity or creative expression the way more imaginative literature does. It's a character study and social commentary, not an invitation to explore or build.

Safe
35

This book contains significant mature content that would be shocking for younger readers: the climax involves George shooting Lennie in the head to spare him from a lynch mob. Earlier, Lennie accidentally kills a woman by breaking her neck. There's pervasive use of racial slurs (the n-word), ableist language ('crazy,' 'dumb'), and sexual references including discussion of brothels. A character shoots his old dog in a scene that parallels the ending. The violence isn't gratuitous but it's real and disturbing. Common Sense Media and Amazon both suggest 14+ as appropriate, and many Reddit teachers report even 8th and 9th graders struggling with engagement and finding it heavy.

Enriching
78

This is a genuinely important piece of American literature that offers profound insights into friendship, disability, class, the American Dream, and moral complexity. The ethical questions it raises—about mercy killing, responsibility for others, the impossibility of certain dreams—are sophisticated and worth grappling with. Steinbeck's social commentary on migrant workers and economic inequality remains relevant. For mature readers ready to engage with tragedy, it builds empathy and critical thinking. It's been a curriculum staple for decades for good reason. But it requires emotional maturity and guided discussion to extract its value.

Parent Info
✓

Why It Might Be Great

  • Powerful exploration of friendship, loyalty, and moral complexity that raises questions worth discussing
  • Steinbeck's spare, vivid prose is masterful—every word counts in this tight 100-page novella
  • Important window into Depression-era migrant workers, class struggle, and the American Dream's failures
  • Builds empathy for people with intellectual disabilities and those living on society's margins
  • The kind of book that sticks with you—the ending is devastating but raises profound ethical questions about mercy and responsibility
⚠

What to Watch For

  • The ending involves George shooting Lennie in the head to save him from a mob—it's a mercy killing but deeply disturbing
  • Frequent use of the n-word and other racial slurs, plus pervasive ableist language that reflects the era
  • Lennie accidentally kills a woman by breaking her neck; another character shoots his dog in a parallel scene
  • References to brothels and sexual content, plus a deeply misogynistic portrayal of the only female character
  • Many students find it slow, depressing, and hard to engage with—Reddit is full of teachers whose classes are falling asleep

Conversation Starters

  • "Do you think George made the right choice at the end? What would you have done?"
  • "Why do you think Steinbeck never gives Curley's wife a name? What does that say about how women were seen?"
  • "The dream of the farm keeps George and Lennie going—do you have a dream that helps you through hard times?"
  • "How does the way characters treat Lennie compare to how we think about intellectual disabilities today?"
  • "Why do you think this book gets banned so often? Should schools still teach it despite the language?"

Deep Dive

The 100-page count is a trap. Because it’s a novella, parents often grab this off the shelf thinking it’s a quick weekend win for a kid who needs to check a literary box. In reality, Of Mice and Men is a dense, atmospheric slog that requires more emotional bandwidth than books three times its length. It’s the literary equivalent of a gray, rainy Tuesday in a town where the power just went out.

The "Old Yeller" of High School

If your kid has already cycled through The Outsiders or Where the Red Fern Grows, they know the "beloved thing must die" trope. Steinbeck takes that trope and strips away the sentimentality. The parallel between Candy’s old dog and Lennie isn’t subtle—it’s a neon sign pointing toward the inevitable.

The friction for a modern reader usually comes from the pacing. Steinbeck spends a massive amount of time on the sensory details of the bunkhouse and the riverbank. For a generation used to the "inciting incident" happening on page five, the slow build of George and Lennie’s "dream" of the farm can feel like filler. But that’s the point. You have to feel the weight of their boredom and desperation to understand why the ending hits like a freight train.

Navigating the Classroom Context

This is rarely a book kids pick up for fun. It’s the ultimate book report book for middle schoolers and freshmen because it’s easy to analyze but hard to forget. If your teen is reading this for a grade, the conversation usually shifts to the "mercy killing" at the end.

It’s worth discussing why this book is a staple in the list of books all teens should read despite the controversy. It’s one of the first times many students encounter a story where the "hero" does something objectively horrific out of love. There is no version of this story where everyone goes home happy, and for a kid used to Marvel-style resolutions, that lack of a safety net can be genuinely jarring.

The "Curley’s Wife" Problem

Beyond the racial slurs and the treatment of Lennie’s disability, the biggest hurdle for a 2026 reader is often Curley’s wife. She doesn’t even get a name. She’s framed entirely through the eyes of the men on the ranch, who see her as a "jailbait" distraction or a "tart."

If you’re reading alongside your kid, this is the most productive place to push back. Steinbeck is showing a world where everyone is disposable—the old guy, the Black stable hand, the disabled man, and the only woman. The bleakness isn't just in the plot; it’s in the way these characters are denied basic humanity by everyone around them. It’s a brutal look at the "American Dream" when the dream is already dead.

If They Liked This...

If your teen actually engaged with the themes of friendship and sacrifice here, they might be ready for more complex "bummer" classics. But if they found the 1930s setting too dry, look for modern titles that handle "unlikely duos against the world" without the dusty agrarian vibes. Steinbeck is a master of the gut-punch, but he doesn't offer any sugar to help the medicine go down.

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Of Mice and Men? Put this WISE score on your site