Is the 'bad dog' label too intense for sensitive kids?

It’s a brief moment of tension where the neighborhood dogs gossip about Toby. It serves as a great teaching moment about rumors, and because it's resolved quickly and happily, most kids handle it fine.

What's the art style like?

It's Thyra Heder’s signature watercolor style—very expressive, detailed, and warm. It feels like a 'classic' picture book but with a modern, cinematic sense of perspective.

Is there a specific breed of dog featured?

Toby is a lovable, floppy-eared mutt, and Pancake is a smaller, distinct dog. The book features a whole variety of neighborhood breeds, which is fun for kids who like identifying different dogs.

How long is the read-aloud time?

It’s a standard 40-page picture book. Expect about 5–8 minutes for a thorough read-aloud, more if you stop to look at the details in the neighborhood scenes.

Nose to Nose – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Nose to Nose

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2024

91%

WISE Score

A new dog’s quest for friends goes sideways over a smelly ball, turning a neighborhood misunderstanding into a masterclass in owning your mistakes.

Nose to Nose

book

2024

91%

WISE Score

A new dog’s quest for friends goes sideways over a smelly ball, turning a neighborhood misunderstanding into a masterclass in owning your mistakes.

Jump to

Where to Read

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.

Screenwise Verdict

Nose to Nose is a gorgeous, smart addition to any picture book shelf. It avoids the typical 'be a good friend' platitudes by showing exactly how easy it is for a new kid to get labeled as a troublemaker just because they're lonely and don't know the rules yet.

Thyra Heder is one of the best illustrators working right now, and her ability to show the internal life of a dog—and by extension, a kid—is top-tier. If you're looking for a book that helps your kid understand social dynamics without feeling like a lecture, this is the one.

Age Fit

Perfect for the 4-to-8 crowd, especially kids transitioning to a new school or neighborhood. Younger siblings will enjoy the dog art, but the social nuance lands best with preschoolers and early elementary kids.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

The story centers on restorative justice and the courage it takes to apologize. It models healthy social repair after a neighborhood misunderstanding.

Imaginative

Thyra Heder’s watercolor illustrations provide a rich, dog-eye view of neighborhood dynamics, turning a simple ball-theft into a high-stakes social drama.

Safe

Standard picture book safety; no mature themes, violence, or scary content. The only tension is social misunderstanding.

Enriching

Excellent for teaching empathy and the 'new kid' perspective. It helps kids understand that 'bad' behavior often stems from loneliness or confusion.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Thyra Heder's illustrations are world-class, capturing dog expressions and neighborhood vibes with warmth and humor.
The smelly ball hook is exactly the kind of sensory detail that makes 5-year-olds giggle and stay engaged.
It tackles the anxiety of being new in a way that feels grounded and relatable, not preachy.
The resolution focuses on active repair rather than just saying sorry, which is a great social-emotional takeaway.

⚠

What to Watch For

The 'bad dog' label might feel a little heavy for very sensitive kids who hate seeing characters get in trouble, but the payoff is worth it.

Conversation Starters

"Why did Toby take Pancake's ball in the first place?"
"Have you ever felt like people didn't understand why you did something?"
"What did Toby have to do to make things right with the neighborhood?"
"How do you think Pancake felt when he finally understood Toby just wanted to play?"

Deep Dive

The Social Stakes of a Smelly Ball

Thyra Heder has a specific talent for making small childhood moments feel as big as they actually are. In Nose to Nose, she takes the gut-punch feeling of being the new kid and translates it into dog language. The watercolor illustrations do the heavy lifting here, showing Toby’s isolation and the neighborhood’s growing suspicion with nuance that words alone can't quite hit.

What makes this book stand out in the crowded 'new kid' genre is the focus on the misunderstanding. Toby isn't malicious; he's just desperate for a connection and makes a bad call with a smelly ball. It’s a great entry point for talking to kids about how 'the group' can sometimes get the story wrong, and why it takes real courage to step up and fix a reputation.

If your kid is a fan of Heder's other work like Alfonsina and the Sea or The Bear Report, they'll recognize the same level of detail and emotional intelligence here. It's a great pick for a bedtime read-aloud that actually has something to say about how we treat the people (and dogs) who have just arrived.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Nose to Nose? Put this WISE score on your site