If I Stay – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

If I Stay

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2014

68%

WISE Score

4.8

Amazon

A teen cellist watches from outside her comatose body after a fatal crash, deciding whether life without her family is worth living.

If I Stay

book

2014

68%

WISE Score

4.8

Amazon

A teen cellist watches from outside her comatose body after a fatal crash, deciding whether life without her family is worth living.

4.8

Jump to

Also rated on

4.8

View →

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

If I Stay is emotionally brutal but genuinely moving—a book that takes teen readers seriously enough to explore profound loss and the choice to keep living. The out-of-body framing device works well, giving space to process trauma without drowning in it.

That said, this is not a light read. The entire family dies in the first act. Mia spends the book watching her own comatose body and deciding whether to fight to survive or let go. It's heavy, and it's designed to make you cry.

For the right reader—a mature teen who can handle intense emotions and wants something meaningful—this is powerful stuff. But it's absolutely not for younger kids, sensitive readers, or anyone currently dealing with fresh grief or mental health struggles around life and death.

The 4.8 Amazon rating and enduring popularity suggest it resonates deeply with its audience. Just make sure your teen is ready for it.

Age Fit

Best for ages 14+. This requires emotional maturity to handle intense grief, family death, and existential crisis. Younger teens or those sensitive to loss should wait or read with support.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

The book deals with profound grief and loss—Mia's entire family dies in a car accident—but handles it with emotional honesty rather than exploitation. The love story between Mia and Adam is genuine and supportive, not toxic. However, the core premise is intensely sad: a teenager watching her own body in a coma while deciding whether to live or die. It's emotionally heavy material that requires maturity to process, even if it's handled sensitively.

Imaginative

The out-of-body narrative device—Mia as a ghost observing her own life hanging in the balance—is a creative framing for exploring identity, choice, and what makes life worth living. The book weaves between present crisis and flashbacks to show how Mia became who she is. It's not wildly inventive as YA goes, but the supernatural-lite premise gives readers a fresh lens on grief and decision-making.

Safe

This is a book about a catastrophic car accident that kills three family members, leaving a teenage girl in a coma deciding whether to live. There's graphic description of the crash aftermath, including Mia seeing her parents' and little brother's bodies. It's not gratuitous, but it's intense and potentially triggering for readers dealing with loss, trauma, or anxiety about death. The content is age-appropriate for mature teens who can handle heavy themes, but it's absolutely not something a younger or sensitive reader should stumble into unexpectedly.

Enriching

If I Stay offers real emotional depth: it explores grief, love, the meaning of family, and the question of what makes life worth living when everything falls apart. Mia's choice—to stay or let go—forces readers to think about resilience, connection, and agency in the face of unimaginable loss. The classical music subplot (Mia is a cellist) adds cultural enrichment. It's genuinely thought-provoking and has sparked meaningful conversations among teen readers about mortality and purpose.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Tackles profound questions about grief, choice, and what makes life meaningful in a way that respects teen readers' emotional intelligence
The out-of-body narrative creates space to explore trauma without being trapped in it—Mia can observe, reflect, and ultimately choose
Strong portrayal of a supportive romantic relationship where both partners have their own identities and dreams
Classical music subplot introduces teens to cello performance and Juilliard ambitions, adding cultural texture
Gayle Forman writes with emotional authenticity—this is a genuine tearjerker that has resonated with millions of readers

⚠

What to Watch For

This is a book about a family dying in a car crash—it's sad, it's intense, and it includes descriptions of the accident aftermath that some readers will find disturbing
Best for emotionally mature teens who can handle heavy grief and existential questions; not appropriate for younger or more sensitive readers
The entire premise is 'should I keep living?'—if your teen is struggling with depression or suicidal thoughts, this might not be the right timing
Expect tears. Lots of them. This is designed to wreck you emotionally (in a cathartic way, but still)

Conversation Starters

"If you were Mia, what would help you decide whether to stay? What makes life worth living even when it's really hard?"
"How do you think Mia's relationship with music shaped who she was? Do you have something like that in your life?"
"The book shows a lot of flashbacks to Mia's family. What do you think Forman was trying to show us about them?"
"Do you think it was fair for Mia to have to make that choice? What would you want people to say to you if you were in her position?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about If I Stay? Put this WISE score on your site