Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is a perfectly fine picture book that does exactly what it says on the tin: a rhyming story about a girl who wants a horse and learns to appreciate what she already has. It's sweet, safe, and wholesome in that Sunday-school-craft-project kind of way.
The problem? It's also pretty forgettable. The 3.8 Amazon rating tells the story—parents bought it hoping for magic, got something serviceable instead. The Christian messaging is gentle but omnipresent (it's part of a 'Pure-As-Gold Seal' series designed to 'plant deep truths'), which is great if that's your jam, less great if you're looking for a universal horse story.
If you've got a 5-year-old who's obsessed with horses and you're okay with faith-based content, this will land just fine. But there are more imaginative, more engaging horse books out there for the same age group. This one works in a pinch but probably won't become a beloved bedtime staple.
Age Fit
Best for ages 4-7, especially horse-loving kids and families who appreciate gentle Christian themes. Older elementary kids will likely find it too young and simplistic.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
78
Sweet mother-daughter dynamic with a gentle lesson about appreciating what you already have. The rhyming story centers on a girl asking for a horse and her mom's creative, loving response. No negativity, models patience and gratitude. Loses a few points for being somewhat saccharine and the 'Pure-As-Gold' Christian branding feels heavy-handed.
Imaginative
62
Colorful artwork and rhyming text offer some visual appeal, plus a hidden warrior game on each page. The premise—wanting something you can't have—is relatable but the execution is fairly predictable. The accompanying draw-your-own-story sketchbook shows some effort to extend creativity beyond the book itself, but the core story doesn't break new ground.
Safe
95
Completely safe for young readers. No concerning content, violence, or mature themes. It's a straightforward picture book about a girl wanting a horse with zero red flags. The Christian messaging is present but gentle (not preachy enough to be jarring). Amazon rating of 3.8 suggests some buyers found it underwhelming but no safety concerns mentioned.
Enriching
58
The central message—you might already have treasures better than what you're asking for—is a decent life lesson about gratitude and perspective. But it's delivered in a fairly simplistic way without much depth. The book plants 'deep truths' according to the author's mission, but in practice it reads more like a basic moral tale. Entertaining enough for the target age but not particularly memorable or impactful.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Gentle mother-daughter bonding story that celebrates the parent-child relationship
Hidden warrior game on each page gives kids something interactive to hunt for
Clean, simple message about gratitude and appreciating what you have
Rhyming text makes it easy for early readers or bedtime read-alouds
⚠
What to Watch For
Christian messaging is woven throughout (part of the 'Pure-As-Gold Seal' series)
That 3.8 Amazon rating suggests it's hit-or-miss—some kids will love it, others will find it forgettable
Pretty predictable plot if your kid prefers stories with more action or surprise
Conversation Starters
"What's something you really, really want right now? Why do you want it so much?"
"Can you think of something you already have that makes you really happy?"
"If you could have any animal as a pet, what would you choose and why?"