Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Let's be crystal clear: this is not a book for kids, teens, or even young adults. Common Sense Media calls it 'graphic rape- and murder-filled,' and that's not hyperbole.

The dark romance genre has exploded on BookTok, and Haunting Adeline sits at the extreme end. It romanticizes stalking, features graphic sexual assault presented as passionate love, and normalizes behavior that in real life would be criminal. The synopsis literally says 'I'll never let her go. Not even when she begs me to.'

For adults who knowingly seek this specific subgenre and can separate fantasy from reality, fine. But the concern is teens finding this through social media recommendations and thinking this represents romance or desirable relationships. It doesn't. This is fantasy fiction that requires significant emotional maturity and a solid foundation in what healthy relationships actually look like.

If you find this in your teen's room, it's time for a serious conversation about consent, boundaries, and the difference between fiction and real-world relationship expectations. This isn't pearl-clutching—it's recognizing that content this extreme can genuinely warp developing ideas about intimacy and safety.

Age Fit

This is exclusively for adults (21+). While some mature teens claim they can handle it, the graphic sexual violence and romanticization of predatory behavior make it inappropriate for anyone under 21. Common Sense Media explicitly states it's only suitable for adults.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

5

Common Sense Media explicitly states this is a 'graphic rape- and murder-filled novel.' The synopsis describes a stalker narrative romanticizing obsessive surveillance and control ('I'll never let her go. Not even when she begs me to'). This models deeply unhealthy relationship dynamics, glorifies non-consensual behavior, and normalizes predatory patterns. The emotional tone is disturbing and psychologically harmful.

Imaginative

35

The dark romance/stalker genre offers a specific aesthetic and psychological tension that some adult readers find compelling. The dual perspective structure (manipulator vs. shadow) provides narrative complexity. However, the imagination here is limited to well-trodden dark romance tropes without meaningful innovation. It's imaginative in execution but not in concept.

Safe

0

This book contains graphic rape, murder, and romanticized stalking. Common Sense Media confirms it's only suitable for adults. The author explicitly directs readers to check content warnings on their website, signaling extreme material. The synopsis itself describes non-consensual surveillance, obsession, and refusal to respect boundaries ('Not even when she begs me to'). This is categorically unsafe for children and would be deeply traumatic if encountered unexpectedly.

Enriching

10

While adult dark romance can explore complex psychological themes, this book romanticizes sexual violence and predatory behavior, which actively undermines healthy understanding of consent, relationships, and boundaries. The 4.4 Amazon rating and strong Goodreads engagement (43% 5-star) suggest entertainment value for its target audience, but there's no evidence of meaningful growth, ethical insight, or skill-building. The glorification of stalking and assault is anti-enriching.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

For adults who specifically seek dark romance with extreme content, it delivers on its genre promises
The dual-perspective narrative structure provides psychological complexity
Strong engagement from its target audience (4.4 Amazon rating, 370K+ 5-star Goodreads reviews)
Author is transparent about content warnings and directs readers to check them beforehand

⚠

What to Watch For

Graphic rape scenes that are romanticized rather than condemned
Stalking behavior portrayed as romantic and desirable
Murder and extreme violence throughout
Psychological manipulation and complete disregard for consent presented as love
Ends on a cliffhanger requiring the sequel
Despite some teen reviewers claiming maturity can handle it, Common Sense Media is clear: this is not appropriate for minors

Conversation Starters

"This is not a book for family discussion—it's adult content that requires mature processing of sexual violence"
"If discovered in a teen's possession: 'I need to talk to you about the difference between fantasy fiction and healthy relationships'"
"For adult book clubs: 'Where's the line between exploring dark themes and romanticizing abuse?'"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic