Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is Shel Silverstein doing what he does best: making poetry feel like playtime. 'Falling Up' has the same magic as 'Where the Sidewalk Ends' and 'A Light in the Attic'—weird characters, clever wordplay, occasional bathroom humor, and that rare ability to speak to kids without talking down to them.
The poems range from pure nonsense (in the best way) to surprisingly thoughtful observations about childhood. Some will make your kid giggle uncontrollably, others might spark real conversations. The line drawings are simple but perfectly capture the absurdity of each poem.
Is it as iconic as 'Where the Sidewalk Ends'? Maybe not quite, but it's still top-tier children's poetry. The 4.9/5 Amazon rating and enthusiastic parent reviews tell the real story: this is a book kids actually want to read, and that's worth its weight in gold. If you're looking for something that builds literacy skills while making reading feel like fun rather than work, this is it.
Age Fit
Perfect for ages 5-12, whether reading independently or as a read-aloud. Younger kids (4-5) will enjoy having it read to them and looking at the drawings. Older kids and adults still appreciate Silverstein's wit and wordplay—this isn't a book you age out of completely.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Silverstein's signature blend of silly, thoughtful, and occasionally bathroom humor captures childhood authentically without being mean-spirited or cynical. The tone is playful and inclusive, celebrating weirdness and imagination. Some poems touch on mild bodily humor (standard for the genre), but nothing crosses into crude territory. Models acceptance of quirky characters and unconventional thinking.
Imaginative
95
Pure creative fuel. Silverstein's wordplay, absurd scenarios (the Nose Garden, the Human Balloon, a dancing bear named Danny O'Dare), and whimsical line drawings invite kids to see language and storytelling as playgrounds. The poems encourage lateral thinking and celebrate the strange and unexpected. This is the kind of book that makes kids want to write their own poems and draw their own weird characters.
Safe
92
Extremely safe. No violence, scary content, or mature themes. Some bathroom humor and silly gross-out moments (typical Silverstein), but nothing shocking or inappropriate. One Common Sense Media kid reviewer called it 'the most inappropriate installment' of Silverstein's work, but this appears to be an outlier opinion referring to mild potty humor. The vast majority of reviews praise it as age-appropriate and fun.
Enriching
86
Builds vocabulary, rhythm, and phonemic awareness through clever wordplay and rhyme. Silverstein's observational humor teaches kids to look at the world differently and find joy in small absurdities. The poems range from pure silly entertainment to genuinely thoughtful observations about childhood, fear, and growing up. Not didactic or preachy—the enrichment comes through engagement with language and ideas rather than moral lessons.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Silverstein's signature mix of silly, profound, and absurd—poems about screaming Millie, a girl with 25 eels, and a human balloon that stick in your head for decades
The kind of book that makes reluctant readers actually want to read, and inspires kids to try writing their own poems
Playful language and rhythm that builds phonemic awareness and vocabulary without feeling like homework
Timeless appeal—adults who grew up on 'Where the Sidewalk Ends' will love sharing this with their kids
Celebrates weirdness, curiosity, and seeing the world sideways—exactly what childhood should be about
⚠
What to Watch For
Some mild bathroom humor and gross-out moments (burps, boogers, the usual Silverstein fare)—totally age-appropriate but worth knowing if your kid is sensitive
A few poems touch on slightly darker themes (fear, loneliness) in that classic Silverstein way—nothing traumatic, just real
Not every poem will land with every kid—some are silly, some are thoughtful, some are just plain weird
Conversation Starters
"Which poem made you laugh the hardest? Want to read it to me again?"
"If you could write a Shel Silverstein-style poem about our family, what would it be called?"
"What's the weirdest character in this book? Want to draw your own weird character?"
"Do you think falling UP would be better or worse than falling down? Why?"
"Which poem would you want to turn into a short movie or cartoon?"