How big is the 'Big, Big Lap Edition' actually?

It is roughly 12 by 12 inches. It won't fit on a standard small bookshelf, but it's perfect for laying flat on a lap so two or three kids can see the pictures at once.

Is it actually scary for a 2-year-old?

Not really. The 'spooky' things are revealed to be silly or harmless almost immediately. It's more about the idea of being nervous than actual fear.

Does this book have 'tricks' or just 'treats'?

As the synopsis says, it's 'all treat.' There are no jump scares or mean pranks; it's a very safe, cozy holiday vibe.

Is the text different from the original 2016 board book?

No, the text and illustrations are identical to the original version. The only difference in this 2025 release is the physical size of the book.

Eek! Halloween! – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Eek! Halloween!

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2025Juvenile Fiction

94%

WISE Score

Nervous chickens mistake a flickering pumpkin for a monster in a rhyming board book that handles spooky themes with the gentlest possible touch.

Eek! Halloween!

book

2025, Juvenile Fiction

94%

WISE Score

Nervous chickens mistake a flickering pumpkin for a monster in a rhyming board book that handles spooky themes with the gentlest possible touch.

Jump to

Where to Read

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.

Screenwise Verdict

Sandra Boynton is the GOAT of the board book world for a reason. This oversized 2025 edition of her Halloween classic is exactly what you want for a toddler who isn't ready for actual scares. It is rhythmic, silly, and ends with a reminder that the holiday is all about fun.

If you already own the pocket-sized version, the 'Big, Big Lap Edition' is basically the IMAX version of the same story. It's a great choice for library story times or just making the art feel a bit more immersive for a kid who usually tries to flip the pages too fast.

Age Fit

Perfect for the 0 to 4 crowd. It is a board book designed for small hands and short attention spans, though the oversized edition is specifically great for 'lap time' with a parent.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

It is Sandra Boynton doing what she does best: gentle humor, rhythmic text, and a total lack of mean-spiritedness. The chickens are nervous, but the payoff is always a silly reveal rather than a genuine scare.

Imaginative

Boynton’s characters—specifically those perpetually anxious chickens—have a distinct personality. The 'spooky robot' and oversized mice are fun, imaginative twists on standard holiday tropes.

Safe

100

It is a board book for toddlers. There are zero content risks. Even the 'scary' elements are immediately defused by the text.

Enriching

The rhythm and rhyme are top-tier for phonological awareness in toddlers. The oversized lap edition format encourages physical closeness and shared attention during reading.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Boynton's signature rhythm makes this a joy to read aloud; the cadence is predictable in the best way for young ears.
The oversized lap edition (new for 2025) is massive, making the illustrations easy for a squirmy toddler to track from a distance.
It provides a gentle entry point to Halloween concepts like witches and wizards without any actual nightmare fuel.

⚠

What to Watch For

The 'spooky robot' and 'mouse of enormous size' are meant to be funny, but a very literal-minded 2-year-old might need a second to realize they aren't real threats.

Conversation Starters

"Which of those costumes was your favorite?"
"Why do you think the chickens were so nervous?"
"What would you say to a chicken who was feeling scared?"

Deep Dive

The Boynton Magic

There is a specific kind of magic in Sandra Boynton’s work that many authors try to replicate and fail. It’s the combination of deadpan animal humor and a meter that never stumbles. In Eek! Halloween!, she takes the standard 'spooky' checklist—dark skies, glowing eyes, witches—and filters it through the perspective of her signature anxious chickens.

Why the 2025 Edition Matters

This specific release is the oversized lap edition, which clocks in at roughly 12x12 inches. For a typical board book, that’s huge. While the content is the same as the 2016 original, the scale changes the experience. It turns the book into a shared event. If you have a kid who likes to point at every detail—the flickering eyes of the pumpkin or the wizard's hat—this format gives them a much larger canvas to work with.

Literacy Notes

From a literacy perspective, this is a 'Reading Rope' powerhouse for the language comprehension strand. The rhyming structure helps kids predict the next word, which is a foundational step in phonological awareness. Because the vocabulary includes words like 'enormous' and 'flickering,' it’s also a sneaky way to build a toddler’s word bank while they think they’re just looking at funny chickens.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Eek! Halloween!? Put this WISE score on your site