Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is exactly what a great picture book should be: funny, surprising, and sneakily teaching kids about empathy without feeling like a lesson. Tabor's won a pile of medals for good reason—he knows how to craft a story that lands.
The premise is genius: everyone thinks Crow is just a jerk, but he's actually monitoring an incoming asteroid and waiting for mission control to give him orders. It's the kind of twist that makes kids want to immediately reread the book to catch all the clues they missed.
Kirkus gave it a starred review and called it 'storytelling at its most brilliant,' and they're not wrong. The illustrations are playful, the pacing is perfect, and there's even a secret code to decode. It's entertaining enough that parents won't mind the inevitable requests to read it seventeen times in a row.
Solid addition to any home library, especially if your kid is in that early reader sweet spot or loves books with a good surprise ending.
Age Fit
Perfect for ages 4-8, especially early readers who love Mo Willems or Jon Klassen. The humor and illustrations work great for read-alouds with younger kids, while early readers can tackle it independently. Probably too young for kids over 9 unless they're reading to siblings.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92
Models friendship, empathy, and understanding that people's behavior often has hidden reasons. Crow's crankiness stems from a noble, world-saving mission rather than meanness. The resolution shows friends understanding each other better. Age-appropriate emotional themes handled with humor and warmth.
Imaginative
94
Corey R. Tabor is a three-time Geisel Medal and Caldecott Honor winner known for his 'Tabor twist' storytelling. The premise—a cranky crow who's actually saving Earth from an asteroid—is wonderfully inventive. Playful illustrations, whimsical humor, and a secret code included in the book all encourage creative engagement. Kirkus calls it 'storytelling at its most brilliant—and whimsical.'
Safe
98
Picture book with no content concerns whatsoever. The 'world-saving' premise is handled with humor and age-appropriate lightness. No scary imagery, violence, or inappropriate themes. Completely safe for young readers.
Enriching
88
Explores social-emotional themes like understanding others' perspectives, the importance of communication, and not judging people by their mood. Introduces science concepts (asteroids, space) in an accessible, fun way. The narrative teaches that people who seem unfriendly might have important things going on. Strong entertainment value paired with meaningful lessons about empathy and friendship.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Corey R. Tabor is a three-time Geisel Medal winner who knows exactly how to nail the picture book format—this has his signature surprise twist that'll make kids (and adults) laugh
Teaches empathy without being preachy: sometimes cranky people aren't mean, they're just busy saving the world
Playful illustrations and humor that works for both kids and parents reading aloud
Introduces space/science concepts (asteroids!) in a fun, accessible way that might spark curiosity
Includes a secret code for kids to decode—nice interactive bonus
⚠
What to Watch For
Crow repeatedly says 'kaw!' in a cranky way—might inspire some loud cawing around the house
The humor is subtle and understated; some kids might need help catching all the jokes on first read
Conversation Starters
"Have you ever been in a bad mood because you were worried about something important? How did your friends react?"
"What would you do if you found out an asteroid was coming toward Earth?"
"Why do you think Crow didn't just tell his friends what he was doing?"
"Can you crack the secret code in the book? What does it say?"