Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Sally Rooney is the queen of the 'sad girl' aesthetic for a reason. This isn't a beach read where everyone ends up happy; it’s a clinical dissection of how people hurt each other while trying to be 'modern.'
If your teen is into literary fiction or wants to feel like they’re reading something 'grown-up,' this is the gold standard. Just know that it deals with infidelity and self-harm head-on. It’s not 'brain rot,' but it is definitely emotionally heavy lifting.
Age Fit
16 and up. This is adult fiction through and through. Younger teens will likely find the lack of quotation marks annoying and the existential dread over Dublin rent prices totally unrelatable.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
35
The story centers on an extramarital affair and characters who are often intentionally detached or emotionally cold to one another. It's not 'bad,' but it's the opposite of cozy.
Imaginative
72
Rooney's prose style—stripping away quotation marks and focusing on internal rhythms—is distinct and fresh, even if the Dublin setting is grounded in reality.
Safe
45
Contains explicit sexual content, infidelity, and depictions of self-harm. While 'safe' for an adult reader, it's not something you want a middle-schooler stumbling into without a heads-up.
Enriching
88
It offers a masterclass in modern power dynamics, class anxiety, and the realities of living with a chronic illness like endometriosis.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Rooney captures that specific brand of 'young and pretentious' perfectly without being annoying.
It treats female friendship as the most important relationship in the book, which is a breath of fresh air.
The depiction of living with endometriosis is raw and actually accurate, not just a plot point.
The dialogue is incredibly realistic, capturing exactly how people talk when they're trying to sound smarter than they feel.
⚠
What to Watch For
The sex scenes are frequent and very descriptive; this isn't a 'fade to black' kind of book.
There is a subplot involving self-harm (cutting) that is handled with gravity but could be a trigger.
The characters can be frustratingly passive-aggressive, which might grate on readers who prefer clear communication.
Conversation Starters
"Is it actually possible to be 'just friends' with an ex like Frances and Bobbi try to be?"
"Why does Frances feel the need to hide her physical pain and her financial struggles from the people she loves?"
"Does being hyper-intellectual make you better at relationships, or just better at making excuses for bad behavior?"
"Who holds the most power in the group—the person with the money, or the person who cares the least?"