Is this book too scary for a 2-year-old?

Not at all. While there are ghosts and dark shadows, they are quickly revealed to be the familiar barnyard animals in costumes. It’s designed to be a 'safe' kind of spooky.

Does it have the same 'typewriter' theme as the original?

Yes, the animals are still using their typing skills to coordinate, though the focus here is more on the sounds of the Halloween night (taps, creaks, and quacks).

Is the board book version different from the hardcover?

The text and art are the same, but the board book is condensed and thickened for smaller hands. It’s the better choice for kids who still tend to rip paper pages.

What's the best way to read this to a group?

Lean into the onomatopoeia. Pause before the 'Click, clack, boo!' and let the kids shout the 'BOO!' part. It turns the book into a game.

Click, Clack, Boo!: A Tricky Treat – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Click, Clack, Boo!: A Tricky Treat

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2019Juvenile Fiction

89%

WISE Score

Farmer Brown tries to hide from Halloween in his footy pajamas, but the cows and ducks have much louder, crunchier plans for the barnyard.

Click, Clack, Boo!: A Tricky Treat

book

2019, Juvenile Fiction

89%

WISE Score

Farmer Brown tries to hide from Halloween in his footy pajamas, but the cows and ducks have much louder, crunchier plans for the barnyard.

Jump to

Where to Read

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.

Screenwise Verdict

This is a seasonal staple for a reason. It takes the familiar, rhythmic DNA of Click, Clack, Moo and gives it a slightly spooky (but mostly silly) coat of paint. If you have a kid in the 'obsessed with farm animals' phase, this is an easy win for the October rotation.

It’s not just a holiday cash-in; it’s genuine literacy practice. By leaning into the sounds of the night, it helps little kids build the language comprehension they need before they ever start decoding words on a page. Plus, Farmer Brown in footy pajamas is a top-tier visual gag.

Age Fit

Perfect for the 1-to-4 crowd. It’s short enough for a toddler's attention span but has enough visual humor to keep a preschooler giggling.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

It's a gentle barnyard comedy where the 'conflict' is just animals wanting to party while a grumpy farmer tries to sleep. No mean-spiritedness, just festive mischief.

Imaginative

The series' signature use of onomatopoeia (the clicks, clacks, and taps) turns a simple reading session into an immersive soundscape for a toddler.

Safe

As a board book for the preschool set, it handles Halloween 'spookiness' with the softest possible touch. The 'surprises' are funny, not frightening.

Enriching

Excellent for phonological awareness. The rhythmic, repetitive sounds are a direct hit for the language-comprehension strand of early literacy.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Phonetic fun that encourages kids to mimic the 'tap, tap, tap' and 'quack, quack, quack' sounds.
Gentle Halloween vibes for kids who aren't ready for anything actually scary but want to feel part of the holiday.
Expressive illustrations by Betsy Lewin that give the animals a hilarious amount of personality without a single line of dialogue.
Durable board book format means it can survive the 'read it again' cycle that toddlers inevitably demand.

⚠

What to Watch For

The 'spooky' atmosphere is limited to dark colors and a few 'creepy' shadows that turn out to be harmless barnyard animals.

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Farmer Brown is so afraid of the dark?"
"What kind of costume would you pick if you were one of the cows?"
"Did you hear any sounds in the book that we can make together?"
"Is Farmer Brown actually mad at the animals, or is he just surprised?"

Deep Dive

The Barnyard’s Best Party

Doreen Cronin and Betsy Lewin have a specific gift for making animals look like they’re getting away with something. In Click, Clack, Boo!, that mischief is directed at Farmer Brown’s attempt to ignore Halloween entirely. While he’s tucked away in bed, the animals are busy throwing the kind of party he’s clearly too 'adult' to appreciate.

What makes this work for toddlers is the rhythm. The book follows a predictable pattern of sounds that builds anticipation. When you're reading this aloud, you aren't just a narrator; you're providing the soundtrack. That kind of co-engagement is exactly what makes early reading stick.

If you're looking for an alternative to the more 'commercial' Halloween books that just list monsters, this is a better bet. It tells a real, albeit tiny, story with a beginning, a middle, and a very cute payoff. It’s a reminder that Halloween can be about treats and tricks without needing to be about terror.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Click, Clack, Boo!: A Tricky Treat? Put this WISE score on your site