Is this movie too preachy for non-religious families?

Yes, it is very likely too niche. The conflict and resolution are deeply rooted in church culture and biblical themes of forgiveness, which might not resonate if that is not your world.

Are there any 'scary' parts when he is in disguise?

Not at all. The disguise is meant for comedic effect and is clearly a prosthetic. There is no 'uncanny valley' horror here, just a pastor in a wig and glasses.

Will my 5-year-old like it?

Probably not. The humor is based on 'generation gap' jokes and church politics. There is not enough physical comedy or visual flair to keep a kindergartner engaged for 90 minutes.

Altar Egos – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Altar Egos

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

movie2017

55%

WISE Score

3.8

IMDb

A pastor glues on a fake beard and joins his own church choir to stop a boycott in this niche faith-based comedy.

3.8/10

→

Altar Egos

movie

G, 2017

55%

WISE Score

3.8

IMDb

A pastor glues on a fake beard and joins his own church choir to stop a boycott in this niche faith-based comedy.

3.8

Jump to

Also rated on

3.8/10

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

It is Mrs. Doubtfire meets a church potluck, but with a significantly lower budget and a lot more sermonizing. If your family lives for the Christian cinema circuit, you know exactly what you are getting here; for everyone else, the 3.8 IMDb rating is a pretty loud warning siren.

The movie is safe to a fault, but it struggles with a 'cringe factor' that makes it hard to recommend for a general audience. It is the kind of movie that plays in the background of a youth group lock-in while everyone is actually looking at their phones.

Age Fit

Best for 8 and up. Younger kids won't find anything inappropriate, but they'll likely be bored to tears by the internal politics of a church Christmas pageant.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

It is a textbook faith-based comedy that prioritizes clean humor and reconciliation. The plot revolves around church community and healing old wounds, though the central deception (the disguise) is a bit of a mixed message.

Imaginative

The 'pastor in a disguise' trope is well-worn territory. It doesn't break new ground in terms of storytelling or visual style, staying firmly within the predictable lanes of its genre.

Safe

Extremely safe. No violence, language, or sexual content. The conflict is entirely based on church politics and interpersonal drama which is safe for all ages to overhear.

Enriching

It attempts to tackle intergenerational conflict and the importance of empathy, but the low production value and weak writing (reflected in its 3.8 IMDb score) hamper the impact of those lessons.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Clean family viewing that avoids the snark and edge typical of modern sitcoms.
Features Robert Amaya and Erin Bethea, two of the biggest names in the mid-2010s faith-based movie circuit.
Focuses on intergenerational empathy, showing the value of listening to the perspective of elderly community members.

⚠

What to Watch For

The 3.8 IMDb rating is a real signal; expect some heavy-handed acting and a plot that moves at a glacial, low-budget pace.
The 'disguise' plot relies on everyone in a small church being remarkably unobservant, which might frustrate kids who prefer tighter logic.

Conversation Starters

"Why did Pastor John feel like he had to lie to get the choir to listen to him?"
"How do you think Mary Margaret felt when she found out who the new guy actually was?"
"Is there someone at our church or in our neighborhood who seems 'unlovable' that we could get to know better?"

Deep Dive

The Faith-Based Comedy Niche

Altar Egos sits in that specific corner of 2010s cinema designed for church movie nights. It stars Robert Amaya (the 'funny guy' from Courageous) and Erin Bethea (Fireproof), which is basically the A-list for this specific genre. If those names mean something to you, the movie will likely land exactly where you expect it to.

The Disguise Trope

The plot is a classic 'undercover boss' setup. Pastor John wants to modernize the Christmas pageant, the traditionalists revolt, and he decides the only way to fix it is to put on a prosthetic face and a cardigan. It is silly, and the movie leans into that silliness, but it also tries to pivot into a serious message about hidden wounds and community healing.

Why the Low Score?

Real talk: it is just not a very well-made movie. The writing is clunky and the pacing is off. While the message is wholesome, the execution feels dated even for 2017. If you want a movie about church life that has a bit more craft, you might be better off with something like The Resurrection of Gavin Stone. But if you are just looking for something clean and harmless to put on while you fold laundry, Altar Egos fits the bill.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Altar Egos? Put this WISE score on your site