Before we dive into specific shows, let's acknowledge what's actually happening here. Riverdale-style teen dramas aren't just about pretty people having problems (though there's definitely that). They're also:

Emotionally heightened versions of real teen experiences. Yes, most high schoolers aren't solving murders, but the feelings of betrayal, identity confusion, and "who can I actually trust?" are very real.

Visually compelling. These shows look good. The cinematography, the fashion, the aesthetics—it's all designed to be aspirational and engaging.

Serialized storytelling that rewards investment. You can't just drop into episode 7. You need the context, the history, the callbacks. For teens who are building their own friend groups and social hierarchies, this kind of complex narrative web feels familiar.

Dealing with "adult" themes in a teen context. These shows let teens explore heavy topics—sexuality, violence, mental health, corruption—from a safer distance than, say, watching Breaking Bad.

The pitch: Four friends are terrorized by an anonymous figure who knows all their secrets. Mystery, drama, and more plot twists than should be legally allowed.

Why Riverdale fans will like it: Similar small-town mystery energy, attractive cast dealing with increasingly wild situations, and that same "wait, WHAT just happened?" feeling every few episodes.

What parents should know: This is the OG of this genre, and it's intense. There's stalking, manipulation, student-teacher relationships that are presented somewhat romantically (yikes), and a lot of gaslighting. The show ran for seven seasons, so there's plenty of content, but the mystery-solving can get exhausting and the "who's A?" question becomes almost comical by season 5. Good for media literacy conversations about how these shows handle serious topics like stalking and consent.

The pitch: Working-class teens search for treasure while navigating class warfare in a coastal North Carolina town. Think Riverdale meets The Goonies with better abs.

Why Riverdale fans will like it: Treasure hunts, forbidden romances, corrupt adults, and teenagers who apparently never need to be home for dinner. The plot moves fast and the stakes feel high.

What parents should know: Less murder-y than Riverdale, but plenty of violence, some drug content, and the kids are constantly in genuinely dangerous situations (like, jumping off boats, getting shot at dangerous). The class commentary is actually more thoughtful than you'd expect, which makes for good discussion. Seasons 1-2 are strongest; it gets progressively more ridiculous from there.

The pitch: Teen girl falls for a vampire in a small town where supernatural drama is the norm. Romance, mythology, and a truly impressive body count.

Why Riverdale fans will like it: Small town with dark secrets? Check. Love triangles that last multiple seasons? Check. Increasingly bonkers plot developments? Oh yes.

What parents should know: This ran for eight seasons and spawned multiple spin-offs (The Originals, Legacies), so there's a LOT of content. The violence is more fantasy-based (vampires, werewolves, witches) rather than realistic, which some parents find easier to handle. The relationship dynamics can be extremely toxic—lots of possessiveness, jealousy, and "I'll die for you" energy that's presented as romantic. Great opportunity to talk about what healthy relationships actually look like.

The pitch: Raw, visually stunning look at teens dealing with addiction, identity, trauma, and relationships.

Why Riverdale fans might be interested: It's what all the older teens are talking about, and it has that same "everyone's watching" cultural moment energy that Riverdale had.

What parents should know: This is not Riverdale. This is significantly more intense, graphic, and mature. We're talking explicit drug use, sexual content, violence, and heavy themes around mental health and trauma. If your teen is under 17, this is probably a pass. If they're 17+, this might be worth watching together or at least having very frank conversations about. The show is actually trying to show the consequences of risky behavior (unlike Riverdale, where consequences are... optional), but it's still a lot. Read our full Euphoria guide before making this call.

The pitch: Manhattan's elite teens navigate wealth, privilege, and an anonymous blogger who exposes all their secrets.

Why Riverdale fans will like it: The drama, the fashion, the "who can you trust?" energy, and that addictive quality of needing to know what happens next.

What parents should know: The original series (2007-2012) is definitely dated in some ways—the slut-shaming, the lack of diversity, some problematic relationship dynamics. But it's also become a cultural touchstone, and there's something to be said for watching it with a critical eye. The 2021 reboot is more diverse and somewhat more aware of its own privilege, but also more sexually explicit. Both versions involve a lot of drinking, some drug use, and teens with essentially no parental supervision.

The pitch: A teen girl leaves behind tapes explaining why she died by suicide, exposing the people she holds responsible.

Why it might come up: If your teen liked Riverdale's mystery elements and serious topics, they might have heard about this one.

What parents should know: This is a hard pass for most families, or at minimum requires watching together and lots of conversation. The show has been controversial since day one for its graphic depiction of suicide, sexual assault, and violence. Mental health experts have raised serious concerns about the show's impact. If your teen is struggling with mental health issues, this is not the show to watch. If you do watch it, absolutely do it together and have resources ready (you can start here).

If your teen wants drama but you want to dial down the intensity, consider:

Rather than just saying yes or no to a show, here are the conversations worth having:

"What do you like about these shows?" Understanding the appeal helps you make better recommendations and shows you're taking their interests seriously.

"How realistic do you think this is?" Teens aren't dumb—they know Riverdale is ridiculous. But talking about what's exaggerated versus what rings true helps build media literacy.

"What would you do differently than this character?" This opens up conversations about decision-making, consequences, and values without being preachy.

"Is there anything in this show that makes you uncomfortable?" Give them permission to tap out or skip episodes. Not everything needs to be watched.

Riverdale fans are looking for shows that make them feel something—whether that's suspense, romance, shock, or just the satisfaction of a good plot twist. The shows on this list all deliver that in different ways.

Your job isn't to find the "perfect" show (it doesn't exist), but to understand what your teen is watching, why they're watching it, and to keep the conversation open. Some of these shows are genuinely well-made with thoughtful themes. Some are absolute trash that's fun to watch anyway. Most are somewhere in between.

The good news? This is actually a great opportunity to stay connected with your teen. Watch an episode together. Make fun of the ridiculous parts. Talk about the serious parts. Let them explain why you're wrong about their favorite character. This is what media literacy looks like in practice—not avoiding everything potentially problematic, but engaging with it thoughtfully.

And hey, if all else fails, there are always seven seasons of Riverdale to rewatch. At least you know what you're getting into there: chaos, abs, and the occasional random musical episode.

Want personalized recommendations? Take the Screenwise survey to get show suggestions based on your family's actual values and your teen's specific interests.

Need to check out a specific show first? Search our media database for detailed breakdowns, age ratings, and parent reviews.

Want to talk through your concerns? Chat with our AI assistant about what might work for your specific situation.