Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is YA fantasy that earned its bestseller status—it's genuinely engaging with a protagonist who has agency and brains. The assassin angle gives it edge without being gratuitously dark in book one, though there's real violence and death throughout.
The 14+ age rating is spot-on. This isn't a book you hand to a 10-year-old who loved Percy Jackson. It's darker, more violent, and morally complex. But for teens ready for that next level of fantasy, it delivers: mystery, political intrigue, romance, and a heroine who can handle herself.
The series gets more intense as it goes (and longer—later books are 600+ pages), so consider book one a test run. If your teen loves it and handles the content well, they've got seven more books waiting. If they're disturbed by the violence or the moral ambiguity of rooting for an assassin, maybe shelf it for a year or two.
Age Fit
Best for 14+ based on violence, death, and moral complexity. The publisher and most parent reviews agree on this range. Mature 13-year-olds who are comfortable with action-heavy fantasy might handle it, but younger readers should wait.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
62
A female assassin protagonist navigating a deadly competition offers strong agency and determination, but the premise centers on violence and murder. Romance elements are present but not explicit in book one. Models resilience and strategic thinking, though the moral complexity of an assassin hero may require discussion. Pacing is solid fantasy adventure without being chaotic.
Imaginative
78
Solid fantasy world-building with a castle competition, mysterious evil force, and political intrigue. The premise of an assassin competing for freedom is creative, and the series has captivated millions of readers worldwide. Not groundbreaking fantasy but engaging enough to spark imagination and has spawned a massive fanbase.
Safe
58
Contains significant violence including multiple deaths, descriptions of ways to kill people, and post-mortem examination scenes. Web sources note 'lots of death' and cursing throughout. Amazon lists reading age as 14+, with parent reviews suggesting 13-14 minimum. Not graphic horror but definitely has content that would be inappropriate for younger readers to encounter unexpectedly.
Enriching
70
Features a competent female protagonist in a male-dominated world, dealing with themes of freedom, loyalty, and survival. Requires strategic thinking as Celaena navigates political intrigue and solves mysteries. The competition format and character relationships offer discussions about power, justice, and morality. Highly entertaining with solid writing that keeps readers engaged, though it's more entertainment-focused than deeply philosophical.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Celaena is a competent, strategic female protagonist who doesn't wait to be rescued—she's doing the rescuing (or the killing)
Mystery elements woven into fantasy adventure keep pages turning; this series has hooked millions of readers worldwide
Explores themes of freedom, loyalty, and survival in a morally complex world where the hero isn't squeaky clean
Gateway to a massive 8-book series that grows with readers as they mature
Strong world-building with political intrigue, romance, and action balanced throughout
⚠
What to Watch For
Significant violence including multiple deaths and Celaena mentally planning ways to kill people—not gratuitous but definitely present
Cursing throughout (though not excessive by YA standards)
Later books in the series get more intense with romance and content, so book one is the tamest
The protagonist is an assassin, which means moral complexity that younger readers may not be ready to process
Conversation Starters
"Celaena is an assassin but we're rooting for her. What makes someone a hero even when they've done terrible things?"
"If you had to compete for your freedom like Celaena, what would be hardest for you—the physical challenges or the moral choices?"
"The king is clearly the villain, but Celaena has to work for him. Have you ever had to cooperate with someone you didn't respect?"
"Why do you think fantasy stories about chosen ones or competitions are so popular? What makes them satisfying to read?"
