This American Life – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

This American Life

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

podcast

68%

WISE Score

Pulitzer-winning storytelling podcast that's brilliant for adults but wildly inconsistent for family listening—you never know what you're getting.

This American Life

podcast

Clean

68%

WISE Score

Pulitzer-winning storytelling podcast that's brilliant for adults but wildly inconsistent for family listening—you never know what you're getting.

Jump to

Also rated on

Screenwise Verdict

This American Life is legitimately great radio—Pulitzer-winning, thought-provoking, beautifully crafted. If you're an NPR household, you probably already know this.

But for family listening? It's a minefield. With 500+ episodes covering everything from whimsical human-interest pieces to heavy investigative journalism, you never quite know what you're getting. One episode might be perfect for a curious 10-year-old; the next could dive into graphic violence or drop F-bombs. There are no content warnings, so car listening with kids is risky.

The show has also shifted over the years—Reddit fans lament that it's become 'ultra-serious, political' compared to its earlier 'vignettes and slices of life' vibe. That's not necessarily bad, but it means less casual family-friendly content.

Bottom line: Fantastic for teens and adults. For younger kids, treat it like a curated library—read episode descriptions first and cherry-pick the ones that fit.

Age Fit

Best for ages 14+ who can handle variable content and appreciate long-form storytelling. Parents can curate specific episodes for younger kids (10+), but you need to preview descriptions first. Not recommended for young children—too much unpredictability and mature content mixed in.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Long-running NPR podcast with thoughtful storytelling and human-interest narratives. Episodes vary widely—some are lighthearted slices of life, others tackle serious political and social issues. Common Sense Media notes parents should preview episodes for younger kids. Recent Reddit discussions suggest the show has shifted toward heavier, more political content than its earlier 'vignettes and slices of life' approach, which may affect emotional tone for family listening.

Imaginative

Ira Glass and team are masters of narrative radio, crafting stories that 'unfold like little movies.' The thematic structure (choosing a weekly theme, then exploring it from unexpected angles) models curiosity and creative thinking. Pulitzer Prize-winning journalism demonstrates originality in the medium. However, it's not interactive or participatory—kids listen passively rather than building or creating.

Safe

Highly variable content across 500+ episodes. Some episodes are family-friendly, others contain mature themes, strong language, or emotionally intense material that could be jarring if overheard unexpectedly. Common Sense Media explicitly advises parents to read episode descriptions before playing for kids. No content warnings on individual episodes make it risky for car listening with children present. The unpredictability is the safety concern—you never know what you're getting.

Enriching

First podcast to win a Pulitzer Prize. Exceptional journalism and storytelling that builds empathy, critical thinking, and understanding of complex social issues. Episodes offer meaningful insights into American life, human nature, and current events. The 'most popular weekly podcast in the world' for good reason—it's intellectually stimulating and emotionally resonant. Strong educational value for teens and adults.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

First podcast ever to win a Pulitzer Prize—genuinely exceptional journalism and narrative craft
Ira Glass is a master at making radio feel cinematic, with stories that stick with you for days
Builds empathy and critical thinking by exploring complex human experiences from unexpected angles
Huge back catalog means you can curate episodes that match your family's interests and maturity level
The thematic structure models curiosity—'let's pick a topic and see where it takes us' is great intellectual modeling

⚠

What to Watch For

No episode-level content warnings, so you can accidentally play something with mature themes, profanity, or heavy emotional content in the car with kids
The show has gotten more political and serious over time—if you loved the lighthearted early episodes, recent ones may feel different
Some episodes tackle intense topics (trauma, violence, systemic injustice) that could be overwhelming or confusing for younger listeners
It's talk radio—kids under 10 will likely zone out unless you specifically choose kid-friendly episodes

Conversation Starters

"What surprised you most about that story? Did you think it would end differently?"
"If you could pick a theme for your own radio show, what would you explore?"
"How do you think the person in that story felt? Would you have made the same choice?"
"That episode talked about [issue]—have you noticed anything like that in our community?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic