Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is Gordon Korman doing what he does best: taking a premise that could be preachy (problem kids + problem teacher = growth!) and making it genuinely funny and emotionally satisfying. The Unteachables works because it doesn't sugarcoat the frustrations on either side—the kids really are difficult, the teacher really has checked out—but it shows how caring and second chances can break the cycle.
The multiple-narrator structure is smart, giving each 'unteachable' kid a chance to explain what's really going on (spoiler: it's usually not what the adults think). Kids will recognize the types—the angry kid, the one who can't read, the one who doesn't belong—and appreciate that Korman treats them as real people with legitimate struggles, not just troublemakers.
It's not groundbreaking literature, but it's a solid, entertaining middle-grade read that sneaks in important messages about empathy, labels, and how low expectations harm everyone. The 4.8 Amazon rating and consistent parent praise suggest it hits the sweet spot of funny enough to keep kids reading and meaningful enough to spark good conversations. A reliable pick for the 8-12 crowd.
Age Fit
Perfect for ages 8-13, especially kids who love school stories with humor and heart. The reading level is accessible for 3rd-4th graders, but the themes about educational inequality and redemption resonate most with middle schoolers who've experienced classroom dynamics firsthand.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Models redemption, empathy, and second chances beautifully. Both the burned-out teacher and the 'problem' students learn to see past labels and discover each other's humanity. The humor is age-appropriate and never mean-spirited. Characters deal with real issues (anger management, reading struggles, false placement) with growing maturity. The tone balances comedy with genuine emotional growth without being preachy.
Imaginative
72
Korman's signature humor and comic mayhem keep things entertaining, with creative classroom chaos and unexpected solutions. The multiple-narrator structure gives readers different perspectives on the same events. However, it's a fairly straightforward school story without fantastical elements or world-building—imaginative in character development and comedic situations rather than in conceptual originality.
Safe
95
Extremely safe content with no concerning elements. Common Sense Media confirms 'comic mayhem' but nothing inappropriate. Addresses sensitive topics (learning disabilities, anger issues, teacher burnout, past cheating scandal) with care and humor. No violence, mature themes, or content that would surprise or shock young readers. The 'difficult discussions' genre tag refers to constructive handling of educational challenges, not traumatic content.
Enriching
85
Tackles important themes about labeling, educational equity, and how low expectations become self-fulfilling prophecies. Kids see that 'problem students' often have legitimate struggles (dyslexia, misplacement) rather than character flaws. The burned-out teacher's arc shows adults aren't perfect either. Builds empathy for kids who are different and shows that caring relationships can transform outcomes. Entertaining enough to keep middle-graders engaged while delivering meaningful messages about second chances.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Gordon Korman delivers his trademark humor with genuine heart—kids will laugh while learning that labels don't define you
Multiple narrators give every 'problem kid' a voice, showing there's always more to the story than what teachers see
Tackles real educational issues (dyslexia, misplacement, burnout) without being a boring message book
Fast-paced and funny enough that reluctant readers will actually finish it
Shows kids that adults mess up too and that caring relationships can change everything
⚠
What to Watch For
Some characters have anger issues and behavioral problems—handled constructively but worth discussing if your kid is sensitive to conflict
The teacher's backstory involves a cheating scandal (he was falsely accused)—good opportunity to talk about unfair judgments
Kids are labeled as 'delinquents' and 'train wrecks' by the system—the book critiques this, but the language is there
Conversation Starters
"Have you ever felt like a teacher or adult didn't believe in you? How did that feel?"
"Why do you think the kids in room 117 acted out so much at the beginning?"
"Mr. Kermit was ready to give up on teaching. What changed his mind?"
"Do you think it's fair to put all the 'problem kids' in one class together? What are the pros and cons?"