Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
If your kid wants a 'Stranger Things' vibe but you aren’t ready for them to deal with 80s teen angst or demogorgons, this is the move. Margaret Peterson Haddix has a knack for taking a high-concept 'what if' and grounding it in real kid emotions.
The story is a slow-burn mystery that turns into a sci-fi puzzle. It’s clean, it’s clever, and it actually makes you think about how the choices people made twenty years ago still ripple through a small town today. It’s a solid win for a weekend read or a long car ride.
Age Fit
Perfect for the 9-13 crowd. It’s the ideal 'step-up' book for kids who want a mystery with some weight but aren't ready for the romance or cynicism of YA novels.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92
The story focuses on a genuine, supportive friendship between two kids who feel like outsiders. It avoids toxic 'mean girl' tropes and portrays adults as complex people rather than just obstacles.
Imaginative
89
The 'time-slip' concept—where echoes of the past physically manifest in the woods—is a clever and haunting twist on standard time travel. It encourages kids to think about the layers of history in their own towns.
Safe
96
Extremely safe middle-grade fiction. There is mild tension and a mention of a past house fire/accident, but no gore, no language, and no sexual content.
Enriching
84
It prompts kids to consider empathy and the idea that their parents were once young people with their own mistakes and secrets. It’s a great bridge into more complex sci-fi themes.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
It’s a 'thinking kid's' mystery that rewards paying attention to small details.
The sci-fi elements (time-slips) are handled in a way that’s smart but never confusing.
Margaret Peterson Haddix is the queen of middle-grade suspense; she knows exactly how to hook a 10-year-old.
It deals with the 'new kid' struggle in a way that feels emotionally honest rather than cliché.
⚠
What to Watch For
The plot involves a past tragedy (a house fire) that might be a little heavy for very sensitive readers.
The characters do a fair amount of sneaking around the woods at night—classic adventure stuff, but worth a talk if you've got a strict rule-follower.
Conversation Starters
"If you could see a 10-second replay of one moment from your parents' childhood, what would you pick?"
"Why do you think Charley was so protective of the 'Remarkables' even before he knew who they were?"
"If you saw people appearing and disappearing in your backyard, would you tell someone or keep it a secret?"
