The Punisher – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

The Punisher

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

show2017

35%

WISE Score

8.4

IMDb

Marvel's most brutal series: a traumatized veteran shoots everyone who deserves it (and the show makes you wonder if that's actually heroic).

8.4/10

→

The Punisher

show

TV-MA, 2017

35%

WISE Score

8.4

IMDb

Marvel's most brutal series: a traumatized veteran shoots everyone who deserves it (and the show makes you wonder if that's actually heroic).

8.4

Jump to

Also rated on

8.4/10

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

Look, this is a well-made show with an incredible lead performance. Bernthal is mesmerizing, the action is top-tier, and it actually tries to grapple with the trauma and consequences of violence instead of just celebrating it.

But let's be clear: this is not for kids, not for teens, not even for most 17-year-olds. It's brutally violent, morally murky, and relentlessly grim. The controversy around its release timing (mass shootings) wasn't unfounded—watching a guy solve all his problems by shooting people is... a lot, even when the show tries to show it's destroying him.

For adults who like dark crime dramas and can stomach the violence, it's compelling television. The IMDB 8.4 rating reflects that it's genuinely good at what it does. But 'what it does' is show a traumatized man murder his way through New York, and that's a tough sell even for mature viewers.

If you're looking for Marvel content, this is as far from Spider-Man as you can get. It's The Sopranos with a skull vest.

Age Fit

This is strictly adults-only content—18+ minimum. The graphic violence, mature themes, and moral complexity make it inappropriate for teens. Even mature 17-year-olds should approach with caution. This is for grown-ups who can handle extremely dark, violent content and want to think about the cost of revenge.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

This is one of the most violent, gritty Marvel series ever made. Frank Castle's vigilante justice involves brutal torture, execution-style killings, and constant moral ambiguity. While it explores PTSD and veteran issues with some nuance, the core premise—that killing bad guys is the answer—isn't exactly modeling healthy conflict resolution. The tone is dark, heavy, and relentlessly bleak.

Imaginative

It's a fairly standard revenge-thriller framework dressed in Marvel branding. The action choreography is well-executed and the exploration of military trauma adds some depth, but it doesn't break new ground in storytelling. It's competent crime drama, not groundbreaking television. The 'what if a guy just shot all the bad guys' premise isn't particularly imaginative in 2025.

Safe

Extremely graphic violence including torture, point-blank executions, brutal hand-to-hand combat with bone-breaking and blood spray. Heavy themes of PTSD, suicide, war trauma, and loss. The show aired amid controversy about glorifying gun violence following real-world mass shootings. This is absolutely not safe for kids or unexpected viewing—it's TV-MA content that earns every bit of that rating.

Enriching

There's genuine exploration of veteran PTSD, survivor's guilt, and the cost of violence. Jon Bernthal's performance is phenomenal and the show doesn't shy away from showing that Frank's path destroys him as much as his enemies. It raises real questions about justice vs. revenge, though it never fully commits to condemning its protagonist. For mature viewers, there's substance here beyond the gunfights.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Jon Bernthal delivers a career-defining performance as Frank Castle—raw, broken, and completely committed
Genuinely explores PTSD, veteran trauma, and the psychological cost of violence in ways most action shows skip
The action sequences are visceral and expertly choreographed—this is brutal, realistic combat
Doesn't sugarcoat consequences: everyone pays a price for violence, including Frank
Strong supporting cast and compelling conspiracy plot beyond just 'guy shoots bad guys'

⚠

What to Watch For

Extremely graphic violence—torture, executions, brutal hand-to-hand combat with serious gore
Released during heightened sensitivity about gun violence; some found it glorifying, others thought it was critical examination
Relentlessly dark and heavy—this is not escapist entertainment, it's a bleak slog through trauma
The central premise (vigilante justice via murder) is morally complicated at best
Strong language, some sexual content, and pervasive themes of death and loss

Conversation Starters

"Do you think Frank Castle is a hero or a villain? Can someone do terrible things for good reasons?"
"How does the show portray the effects of war and PTSD? Does it feel realistic or exploitative?"
"Is there ever a situation where taking the law into your own hands is justified?"
"How do you think Frank's family would feel about what he's become?"
"The show came out right after several mass shootings—do you think it glorifies gun violence or critiques it?"

Deep Dive

The Marvel branding trap

If your household has spent the last decade following the Avengers, you’ve likely developed a certain level of comfort with the Marvel logo. You expect some quips, some CGI explosions, and a generally heroic arc where the good guy wins without getting too much blood on the suit. The Punisher is the hard pivot away from that safety. It exists in a corner of the universe where there are no aliens or magic hammers, just a broken Marine veteran with a massive amount of firepower.

The biggest risk here is the "superhero" label. If a kid sees Frank Castle in a comic or a LEGO set and asks to watch his show, they are walking into a gritty crime drama that has more in common with Heat or Sicario than Captain America. Before you let a teenager talk you into this, it’s worth checking Marvel Movie Ratings: From 'I Am Groot' to 'Deadpool & Wolverine' to see where the line is drawn between PG-13 fun and TV-MA brutality.

It’s a character study, not a comic book

What makes this show actually good—and it is very good, as that IMDB 8.4 suggests—is that it doesn’t treat violence like a game. Jon Bernthal plays Frank Castle as a man who is essentially haunted. The show spends a significant amount of time on the psychological toll of war and the isolating nature of grief. It’s a slow burn. There are long stretches where nothing explodes, and instead, we’re watching veterans sit in a circle and talk about how hard it is to come home.

This depth is what separates it from mindless action, but it’s also what makes it so heavy for younger viewers. The show asks uncomfortable questions about whether a person who has lost everything can ever really be "fixed." If you’re trying to help a mature teen navigate these themes, our guide on The Superhero Paradox: Navigating the New Era of 'Good Guy' Violence offers a way to talk about why we’re drawn to these dark "justice" stories.

Where the friction lives

The violence in The Punisher is intimate. It isn’t the bloodless, "bad guys fall down and disappear" style of the main MCU films. It is messy, loud, and frequently involves torture or point-blank executions. The show was released during a period of intense cultural debate regarding gun violence, and you can feel that tension in the script. It doesn't always land on the side of "guns are the solution," but it certainly spends a lot of time showing them in action.

If you’ve already opened up your streaming settings to allow for grittier content, you might want to double-check Disney Plus Age Ratings: How to Block TV-MA and R Content. This show is the reason those parental controls exist. While something like The Boys uses gore for shock value or satire, The Punisher uses it to show that violence is consequential. It’s a show for adults who want to sit with the darkness for a while, not for a family movie night.

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic