Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Look, The Pacifier is the definition of 'fine.' It's not going to hurt anyone, but it's also not going to enrich anyone's life in any meaningful way.

The critics absolutely savaged it (21% on Rotten Tomatoes, 30 on Metacritic), and even general audiences were lukewarm at best. The premise—tough Navy SEAL learns to babysit—had potential, but it's executed with all the subtlety of a sledgehammer and the creativity of a paint-by-numbers kit.

The biggest issue? It's just so 2005. The humor feels stale, the pacing drags, and the whole thing has that glossy, forgettable Disney Channel Original Movie vibe (except it got a theatrical release). Kids today are used to Pixar's emotional depth, Marvel's wit, or at minimum, something that doesn't feel like it was made two decades ago.

Is it safe? Sure. Will it teach your kids anything valuable? Maybe that even tough guys can learn to be gentle, but that message gets buried under fart jokes and pratfalls. Will they enjoy it? Possibly, if they're in that sweet spot of 7-10 and not too discerning. Will they ask to watch it again? Highly doubtful.

Bottom line: If it's already queued up on Disney+ and you need 90 minutes of peace, go for it. But don't go out of your way to make this a family movie night selection—there are literally hundreds of better options.

Age Fit

Best for 7-11 year olds who aren't picky about dated humor and just want something easy. Older kids will roll their eyes at the corniness, and younger ones might find the action bits a touch intense.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

68

Family comedy that models a tough military character learning patience, empathy, and how to care for children. Shows growth in understanding different perspectives and the importance of family. Some slapstick humor and mild potty jokes typical of mid-2000s Disney fare, but overall positive messages about cooperation and overcoming differences. Pacing is energetic but not chaotic.

Imaginative

42

Fairly formulaic 'fish out of water' setup with predictable plot beats. The premise of a Navy SEAL babysitting is mildly creative but executed in standard Disney comedy fashion. Doesn't invite much creative thinking or exploration—kids watch passively rather than being inspired to imagine or create. The spy/government scientist subplot adds minimal intrigue.

Safe

75

Disney movie with age-appropriate action sequences (no graphic violence or gore). Some mild peril and chase scenes but nothing traumatic. No sexual content, minimal language concerns. The deceased father backstory is handled gently. Common Sense Media rates it for age 10, likely due to action intensity rather than inappropriate content. No surprise disturbing elements for a family comedy.

Enriching

48

Light entertainment with surface-level lessons about patience, teamwork, and accepting help from others. Vin Diesel's character learns to be less rigid, but the growth is predictable and shallow. Kids might pick up messages about trying new things (like theater) and not judging people by appearance, but these aren't deeply explored. More cotton candy than nutritious meal—entertaining but forgettable.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Harmless family entertainment that won't traumatize anyone—pure popcorn fodder
Shows a tough guy learning to be nurturing and vulnerable, which is a decent message
Physical comedy and slapstick might land with younger elementary kids
Available on Disney+ for easy streaming when you need 90 minutes of distraction

⚠

What to Watch For

This is peak mid-2000s cheese—the humor, pacing, and style feel very dated
Some mild action sequences and peril (it's about protecting kids from bad guys)
Potty humor and slapstick that was barely funny in 2005
Your kids will probably forget they watched it within 24 hours

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Shane had such a hard time understanding what the kids needed at first?"
"What's something you're good at that adults might not expect?"
"Have you ever had to work with someone really different from you? How'd that go?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic