Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the deal: This movie looks expensive and pretty, with elaborate costumes and sets that clearly cost a fortune. But it's the definition of style over substance.

The plot is a confusing mess that even adults struggle to follow, the characters are paper-thin, and the whole thing feels like a soulless algorithm tried to reverse-engineer a Disney classic. The reviews don't lie—32% on Rotten Tomatoes is brutal for a big-budget Disney release, and the 2.5/5 on Letterboxd means even generous viewers were underwhelmed.

It's safe enough for family viewing and has some nice messages about courage and self-discovery, but your kids will probably get bored halfway through and ask to watch something else. There are dozens of better fantasy adventures on Disney+ that actually deliver on story and heart (Moana, Encanto, even Frozen if you can stand it again).

If your kid is obsessed with ballet or the Nutcracker specifically, maybe give it a shot. Otherwise, skip it. Life's too short for mediocre movies, even pretty ones.

Age Fit

Best for ages 7-11 who enjoy fantasy adventure and can handle some mild peril. The Common Sense Media age 8+ recommendation feels right—younger kids may be bored or confused by the convoluted plot, while tweens and teens will likely find it too juvenile and forgettable. Not one that adults will enjoy alongside kids.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

68

Features a young female protagonist on a journey of self-discovery with themes of family, courage, and finding inner strength. The story centers on Clara honoring her late mother's memory, which models healthy grief processing. Tone is generally uplifting and cooperative, though some darker fantasy elements (Fourth Realm conflict) may feel slightly intense for very young viewers. No meanness or cynicism.

Imaginative

72

Creates four distinct fantasy realms (Land of Snowflakes, Land of Flowers, Land of Sweets, Fourth Realm) with elaborate visual world-building. The premise of a magical key unlocking secret worlds invites wonder and exploration. However, the execution leans heavily on visual spectacle over truly original storytelling—it's derivative of both the Nutcracker ballet and standard Disney princess-quest formulas. Still, the fantastical elements and production design offer solid imaginative fuel for kids.

Safe

75

Rated PG with Common Sense Media suggesting age 8+. Contains some fantasy action/peril and mildly scary imagery (tin soldiers, a somewhat menacing Mouse King, dark realm atmosphere) but no gore, graphic violence, or inappropriate content. The mother's death is a plot point but handled gently and off-screen. Some younger or sensitive kids might find certain sequences tense, but nothing shocking or traumatizing. Standard Disney fantasy fare in terms of safety.

Enriching

58

Offers themes about courage, self-reliance, and honoring family legacy. Clara's journey involves problem-solving and standing up for what's right. However, the story is fairly surface-level with predictable beats and limited emotional depth. The abysmal critical reception (32% RT critics, 36% audience, 2.5/5 Letterboxd) suggests the film doesn't deliver meaningful insight or lasting impact. It's entertaining enough in the moment but forgettable—more empty calories than nourishment.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Stunning costumes and production design—it's genuinely gorgeous to look at, with elaborate sets and ballet sequences
Positive female protagonist who solves problems through courage and cleverness rather than waiting to be rescued
Gently handles themes of grief and loss, showing Clara honoring her mother's memory in a healthy way
Short enough (under 2 hours) that even if kids lose interest, you're not trapped for ages

⚠

What to Watch For

Some darker fantasy sequences and mildly creepy imagery (Mouse King, ominous Fourth Realm) that might spook sensitive kids under 7
Mother's death is a central plot point—handled delicately but worth noting if your child is processing grief
The story is confusing and poorly paced—even kids may struggle to follow or care about what's happening
Universally panned by critics and audiences alike; don't expect a magical experience just because it's Disney

Conversation Starters

"Clara found a special gift from her mom that helped her feel connected. What's something that reminds you of someone you love?"
"The four realms all had different qualities—which one would you want to visit and why?"
"Clara had to be brave even when she was scared. When have you had to do something that felt scary?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

The Nutcracker and the Four Realms