The Muppets – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

The Muppets

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

show2015

55%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

The Muppets try The Office format—with workplace drama, breakups, and a mockumentary style that nobody really asked for.

64%

7.0

→

The Muppets

show

2015

55%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

The Muppets try The Office format—with workplace drama, breakups, and a mockumentary style that nobody really asked for.

64%

7.0

Jump to

Also rated on

64%

7.0

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

Look, this show tried something different and deserves credit for that. But the execution just didn't land.

The 2015 Muppets reboot asked: what if we took these beloved, anarchic, musical characters and trapped them in a mockumentary workplace sitcom? The answer turned out to be: not great, actually. The show got cancelled after one season because audiences—both kids and adults—weren't feeling it.

The 'adult' angle is overblown marketing speak. There's nothing inappropriate here, just more relationship drama and workplace tension than classic Muppets. But that shift in tone strips away a lot of what made the Muppets special: the joy, the music, the controlled chaos, the heart.

If your kids are Muppet fans, they'll probably watch an episode or two out of curiosity. But this isn't appointment viewing, and honestly, you're better off showing them The Muppet Show reruns or the 2011 movie. This reboot is a curiosity, not a classic.

Age Fit

Best for ages 10-14 who can appreciate workplace sitcom dynamics and won't be bored by the slower pacing. Younger kids expecting classic Muppet zaniness will be disappointed; older teens and adults will likely find it a pale imitation of both The Office and classic Muppets.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

The 2015 reboot aimed for a more 'adult' tone with workplace drama, romantic entanglements, and breakups—a departure from classic Muppet wholesomeness. While still fundamentally kind-hearted characters, the mockumentary format and emphasis on personal dysfunction (Kermit and Miss Piggy's breakup was a major plot point) adds cynicism that dilutes the traditional warmth. Models some cooperation but leans into conflict and relationship drama more than classic Muppets.

Imaginative

The mockumentary/documentary-style format was a creative risk and showed some originality in reimagining the Muppets for a modern TV landscape. However, the 'behind-the-scenes' workplace comedy approach (essentially The Office with felt) felt derivative rather than truly imaginative. Limited the fantastical, anything-goes creativity that made classic Muppets special—fewer musical numbers, fewer wild sketches, more sitcom conventions.

Safe

Still fundamentally a family show with no graphic content, violence, or inappropriate material. The 'adult' angle means more relationship drama, mild innuendo, and workplace tensions rather than anything genuinely unsafe. Some romantic storylines and breakup themes might confuse younger viewers but nothing triggering. The shift in tone is more about sophistication than actual safety concerns.

Enriching

Limited enrichment value compared to classic Muppets. The workplace sitcom format offers some lessons about relationships, collaboration, and handling disappointment, but the cynical tone and focus on dysfunction over growth reduces meaningful takeaways. Entertainment value is moderate—the show was cancelled after one season due to poor reception, suggesting even the entertainment factor didn't land. TMDB rating of 7/10 is middling.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Attempts a fresh, contemporary take on beloved characters with a mockumentary format
Still features the classic Muppet characters kids (and nostalgic adults) know and love
Some workplace and relationship themes could resonate with older kids and parents watching together
No genuinely inappropriate content—safe for family viewing even with the 'adult' marketing

⚠

What to Watch For

Significantly more cynical and drama-focused than classic Muppets—Kermit and Miss Piggy's breakup is a central storyline
The mockumentary format and workplace sitcom structure may bore younger kids expecting traditional Muppet chaos
Cancelled after one season, so storylines don't resolve satisfyingly
Honestly just not that good—even Muppet fans were lukewarm on this reboot

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think the Muppets tried to be more 'grown-up' in this show? Did it work?"
"Which version of the Muppets do you like better—the classic silly one or this workplace comedy style?"
"How do you think Kermit feels about all the drama at work? Would you want to work with Miss Piggy?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic