Here's the truth: The Muppet Show is objectively excellent television from 1976. It's clever, kind, creative, and safe. The ratings are stellar because it genuinely was groundbreaking and beloved.

But it's 2025, and this show is nearly 50 years old. The pacing is slow, the humor is dated, the celebrity guests are people your kids have never heard of, and the variety show format feels like watching a time capsule. Most modern kids will tune out in minutes.

This is a nostalgia play for parents, not a go-to recommendation for kids. If you loved it as a kid and want to share it, go for it—but manage expectations. Your kid might humor you for one episode before asking if they can watch Bluey instead. And honestly? That's fair.

The WISE score reflects both its genuine quality AND the reality that it's a hard sell in 2025. There are better ways to spend screen time unless you're specifically teaching theater history or doing a retro media unit.