The Importance of Being Earnest – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

The Importance of Being Earnest

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book1990

62%

WISE Score

4.6

Amazon

Oscar Wilde's wittiest play—brilliant on stage, but reading Victorian banter on the page is like watching paint dry in a corset.

The Importance of Being Earnest

book

1990

62%

WISE Score

4.6

Amazon

Oscar Wilde's wittiest play—brilliant on stage, but reading Victorian banter on the page is like watching paint dry in a corset.

4.6

Jump to

Also rated on

4.6

View →

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the truth: The Importance of Being Earnest is objectively brilliant—Wilde's wit is razor-sharp, the structure is perfect, and the satire skewers Victorian society beautifully. In performance, it's delightful.

But you're looking at the 1990 Dover edition book, and that's a different story. Reading Victorian drawing-room comedy on the page in 2025 is a slog for most people. The jokes require understanding Victorian marriage markets and class anxiety. The epigrams that sparkled on stage feel dated in print. Eighth-grade teachers on Reddit say their students can handle it, not that they love it.

This is a classic that earns its reputation, but it's homework, not entertainment. If your teen is taking AP Lit or loves theater, great—it's safe, clever, and genuinely funny when you crack the code. For everyone else? Watch the 2002 Colin Firth movie instead. Same wit, way more watchable.

Age Fit

Best for ages 14+ with an interest in classic literature or theater. The language and Victorian social satire require maturity and context that younger readers won't have. Adults studying literature or theater will appreciate it most; it's not entertainment for casual readers.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

A witty comedy of manners that satirizes Victorian society without malice. Characters scheme and lie to escape social constraints, but in service of love and freedom rather than cruelty. The humor is clever wordplay rather than mean-spirited, and the tone remains light throughout. Deception is treated as farce, not moral corruption.

Imaginative

Wilde's linguistic brilliance shines through with scintillating epigrams and clever wordplay that rewards close reading. The play's structure is ingenious—double lives, mistaken identities, and perfectly timed revelations. While it doesn't invite interactive creativity, it models how language itself can be art, showing readers how wit and timing create comedy. The satire invites readers to question social conventions.

Safe

Essentially no content concerns. This is a Victorian drawing-room comedy with no violence, sexuality, profanity, or disturbing themes. The 'scandalous' elements are about characters inventing fake relatives and pursuing marriage—tame by any modern standard. Web searches confirm parents find it appropriate with 'little content of concern.' One Reddit thread suggests 8th graders can handle it comfortably.

Enriching

Offers genuine intellectual value: masterclass in satire, wordplay, and dramatic structure. Exposes the absurdity of rigid social conventions and class pretensions. The epigrams are quotable and thought-provoking. However, enrichment requires understanding Victorian context, which creates barriers. For readers who can access it, there's real insight into how comedy critiques society. Amazon rating of 4.6 suggests readers appreciate it.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Genuinely funny wordplay and epigrams that reward clever readers—Wilde's wit is legendary for a reason
Teaches satire and social commentary through comedy rather than heavy-handed moralizing
Safe, clean content makes it accessible for high schoolers studying literature
Short enough to finish in one sitting (it's a play, not a novel)
Models how language itself can be an art form—every line is crafted for maximum effect

⚠

What to Watch For

Victorian social context is essential to get the jokes—without it, much of the satire falls flat
Written as a play meant to be performed, not read silently; the dialogue can feel stilted on the page
Modern kids will likely find the pacing slow and the concerns (proper names, marriage rules) utterly foreign
Best for teens already interested in literature or theater, not casual readers looking for entertainment

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Jack and Algernon create fake identities? Have you ever felt like you had to be different versions of yourself?"
"The characters obsess over trivial things like names and cucumber sandwiches—what does Wilde think about their priorities?"
"Lady Bracknell says 'To lose one parent may be regarded as a misfortune; to lose both looks like carelessness.' Why is this line funny?"
"How would this story be different if it were set today? What social rules do we follow that might seem silly in 100 years?"

Deep Dive

The "Sheet Music" Problem

Reading a play is not like reading a novel. It is closer to reading sheet music—you can see the notes, but you aren't hearing the symphony. Wilde’s dialogue is meant to be snapped off with precision, not processed silently in a beanbag chair. If you hand this to a teenager without explaining that Jack and Algernon are essentially two "bros" trying to out-snark each other, they will see a wall of Victorian politeness and bail within ten pages.

The magic happens when you realize every character is a monster of ego. Lady Bracknell isn't just a stern grandmother; she is the final boss of social gatekeeping. When she interrogates Jack about his "prospects," she is performing the 1895 version of a background check and a credit score review. If your kid can start "hearing" the sarcasm, the book transforms from a school assignment into a sitcom.

The Victorian Burner Account

The most relatable part of the plot for a 2026 audience is "Bunburying." Algernon creates a fake, sickly friend named Bunbury so he can have a permanent excuse to leave boring parties and skip out on family obligations. Jack creates a fake brother named Ernest so he can pretend to be a "bad boy" in the city while maintaining a "good guy" reputation in the country.

This is essentially the Victorian version of having a finsta or a burner account. It’s the practice of curated identity. We live in an era where everyone manages a public-facing brand and a private reality, which makes Wilde’s satire on the exhaustion of being "earnest" feel surprisingly current. If your teen is already navigating these themes through more intense lenses—like the exploration of family secrets and hidden identities in Fun Home by Alison Bechdel—they might find Wilde’s take to be a refreshing, low-stakes palate cleanser.

How to actually use this

Don't just assign this book. That is a recipe for boredom. Instead, try one of these moves:

The Table Read: If you have a kid who likes theater, grab two copies and read the "Cucumber Sandwich" scene in the first act out loud. If you don't laugh at the sheer absurdity of two grown men arguing over bread and butter, this isn't the book for you.
The "Clueless" Comparison: If your kid liked Clueless or Emma, explain that this is the same vibe but with even more insults. The plot is secondary to the "vibe" and the verbal sparring.
The Epigram Hunt: Wilde is the king of the one-liner. Challenge your reader to find three quotes that would actually work as a social media caption today. "I can resist everything except temptation" still goes hard.

This Dover edition is cheap and portable, but it provides zero help with the historical shorthand. You might need to explain that "the Season" was basically a high-society mating ritual and that being "born in a handbag" is the ultimate 19th-century red flag. Without that context, the ending feels like a random coincidence rather than the hilarious middle finger to the British class system that Wilde intended.

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic