Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the thing: The Hobbit book is a charming, whimsical children's adventure. This movie is a nearly-3-hour CGI battle epic that stretches the story to breaking point. It's visually stunning, sure, and the riddle scene with Gollum is worth the price of admission. But Jackson took a cozy bedtime story and turned it into Lord of the Rings: The Prequel, complete with extended orc beheadings and terrifying warg chases.

Many parents were genuinely surprised by how violent and dark this gets—the age 11 Common Sense rating feels optimistic. If your kid loved LOTR and can handle intense fantasy violence, they'll probably enjoy this. But if you're expecting the gentle tone of the book, prepare for disappointment.

The bigger issue? It's just too long and too bloated. Kids under 10 will struggle with the pacing, and even fans of the book might wonder why a 300-page children's story needed to become three movies. This first installment has its moments of magic, but it's buried under layers of unnecessary CGI spectacle.

Age Fit

Best for ages 12+ despite the Common Sense age 11 rating—many parents reported their 11-year-olds were genuinely scared by the violence and frightening creatures. Teens and adults who enjoy fantasy epics will appreciate the spectacle, though Tolkien purists may grumble about the bloat.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

72

Strong themes of friendship, courage, and loyalty as Bilbo joins the dwarves' quest. Models teamwork and perseverance throughout. However, the extended battle sequences and darker tone compared to the book pull this down slightly—it's more 'epic fantasy war' than cozy fireside tale. The pacing drags in places (nearly 3 hours), which tests patience.

Imaginative

85

Middle-earth is visually stunning and immersive—the Shire, Rivendell, the goblin tunnels, and riddle game with Gollum are genuinely creative and transportive. Peter Jackson's world-building invites wonder and curiosity about fantasy realms, even if it leans heavily on CGI spectacle rather than practical magic. Inspires interest in Tolkien's broader mythology.

Safe

58

PG-13 for good reason. Extended sequences of intense fantasy violence—beheadings (mostly orcs/goblins), sword fights, characters falling to their deaths, a stone giant battle, and genuinely frightening sequences (the pale orc Azog, wargs, goblin king's death). Multiple parent reviews on Common Sense Media expressed shock at the age 11 rating, noting it's more violent than expected. No sexual content or language issues, but the 3D effects amplify the scary factor. Kids under 12 will likely find multiple scenes disturbing.

Enriching

68

Introduces Tolkien's classic themes of heroism, home, and the reluctant hero's journey. Bilbo's character arc—from comfort-loving homebody to brave adventurer—offers solid lessons about stepping outside your comfort zone. However, the film stretches a 300-page children's book into a bloated 3-hour epic, diluting the story's impact. It's more spectacle than substance compared to the source material. Still, it can spark interest in reading and mythology.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Gorgeous world-building brings Middle-earth to life—the Shire, Rivendell, and goblin caves are genuinely magical
Bilbo's journey from reluctant homebody to brave adventurer models courage and stepping outside comfort zones
The riddle game with Gollum is legitimately tense and well-done
Strong themes of loyalty, friendship, and perseverance throughout the quest
Can spark genuine interest in Tolkien's books and fantasy literature

⚠

What to Watch For

Intense fantasy violence—orc beheadings, characters falling to deaths, scary creatures (Azog, wargs, goblins) that frightened many kids under 12
Nearly 3-hour runtime is a serious commitment; younger kids will struggle with pacing
Much darker and more battle-heavy than the whimsical children's book—this is Jackson's LOTR epic style, not bedtime story vibes
The 3D effects amplify the scary factor significantly

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Bilbo decided to leave his comfortable home? Would you have gone on the adventure?"
"What did you think about Gollum? Was he scary, sad, or both?"
"The dwarves lost their home to a dragon. How do you think that would feel?"
"Bilbo didn't think he was brave at first. When did he start to believe in himself?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey