The Hardy Boys / Nancy Drew Mysteries – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

The Hardy Boys / Nancy Drew Mysteries

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

show1977

52%

WISE Score

1970s teen detective series that's wholesome and safe, but so dated it's practically a time capsule—and not the fun kind.

The Hardy Boys / Nancy Drew Mysteries

show

NR, 1977

52%

WISE Score

1970s teen detective series that's wholesome and safe, but so dated it's practically a time capsule—and not the fun kind.

Jump to

Also rated on

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

Let's be real: this show is a fossil. Yes, it's wholesome. Yes, it's safe. Yes, there's mystery-solving and positive role models. But it's 1977, and it looks, sounds, and moves like 1977.

The IMDB 7.3 rating is nostalgia talking—Gen Xers remembering Shaun Cassidy posters, not objective entertainment value. For 2025 kids raised on high-production Netflix and Disney+, this will feel like watching paint dry. The pacing is glacial, the acting is stiff, the mysteries are predictable, and the whole vibe screams 'your parents' childhood.'

If you're trying to introduce your kid to classic mystery formats or you want the absolute safest content imaginable, fine—but manage expectations. This isn't appointment viewing; it's a curiosity at best. There are dozens of better mystery shows for kids that don't require a time machine to enjoy.

Age Fit

Common Sense Media says 9+, which tracks for content safety, but realistically this is for kids 8-11 who either love retro stuff or have parents steering them toward it. Modern teens will bounce off this immediately.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Classic mystery series with teen sleuths modeling problem-solving and cooperation. Age-appropriate tone for family viewing (CSM rates it 9+). No toxic behavior or mean-spirited content. The wholesome factor is genuine—these are earnest, clean-cut kids solving crimes—but the earnestness can feel dated and a bit stiff by 2025 standards.

Imaginative

Mystery-solving format invites logical thinking and deduction, encouraging viewers to piece together clues. The anthology-style structure offers variety. However, the execution is formulaic 1970s TV—predictable plots, limited visual creativity, and zero innovation by modern standards. It doesn't inspire creative expression or exploration beyond 'whodunit' guessing.

Safe

Extremely safe content with no gore, sexuality, or inappropriate material. Mystery-based tension but no graphic violence or trauma. Common Sense Media rates it for age 9, and the IMDB 7.3 suggests broad family appeal. Kids Mode available on Peacock. The mysteries involve danger but it's TV-safe, no surprise disturbing content.

Enriching

Promotes critical thinking, deductive reasoning, and persistence in solving problems. Models positive sibling relationships (Hardy Boys) and independent female protagonist (Nancy Drew). However, entertainment value is severely compromised by 1970s pacing, production values, and acting styles. The enrichment is there conceptually, but the delivery makes it hard to actually absorb for modern viewers.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Genuinely safe mystery content with zero inappropriate material—perfect if you need something squeaky clean
Models problem-solving, critical thinking, and sibling cooperation in a straightforward way
Nancy Drew episodes feature an independent female protagonist solving crimes, which was progressive for 1977
Might work as a 'media history' lesson if your kid is into retro culture or you're feeling nostalgic

⚠

What to Watch For

The pacing is glacially slow by modern standards—kids used to YouTube and TikTok will find this nearly unwatchable
Production values, acting style, and dialogue are peak 1970s cheese—think feathered hair, bell bottoms, and wooden delivery
Your kid will likely tap out after 10 minutes unless they're genuinely fascinated by vintage TV or you're watching together with heavy parental enthusiasm

Conversation Starters

"How do you think detectives solved crimes before smartphones and the internet?"
"What clues did you notice that helped solve the mystery?"
"How is this different from the mystery shows you watch now? What's better or worse?"
"Do you think Nancy Drew was a cool character for girls to see on TV in the 1970s?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic