Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is a solid, well-executed middle grade novel that takes the standard "new school, new friends" premise and gives it a science-lab twist. Maddie is a likable protagonist who feels real—awkward, grieving, analytical, and trying her best.
The book doesn't break new ground in children's literature, but it does what it sets out to do well. The grief processing is honest without being overwhelming, the friendship drama feels authentic, and the STEM framing is genuinely clever rather than forced. It's the kind of book that might help a science-loving kid see that social skills are also learnable—just like experiments.
Not a must-read classic, but a good, enriching choice for the target age that combines emotional growth with a protagonist kids will root for. The 4.6 Amazon rating suggests it connects with its audience, which matters more than critical acclaim for this age group.
Age Fit
Perfect for ages 9-13, especially kids starting or navigating middle school. The scientific angle makes it particularly appealing to STEM-minded readers who might not usually gravitate toward friendship stories. Upper elementary and middle schoolers will recognize the social dynamics.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
82
Handles grief, friendship loss, and middle school transitions with emotional honesty. Maddie's journey through her grandfather's death and social struggles is age-appropriate and models working through difficult feelings. The story shows consequences when she writes unflattering observations about peers in her notebook, teaching empathy without being preachy.
Imaginative
74
The scientific framing is clever—Maddie approaches social problems like experiments, writing Standard Operating Procedures in her lab notebook. It's a fresh angle on the middle school friendship story, encouraging analytical thinking about relationships. However, it's still fundamentally a realistic contemporary story, not wildly inventive or world-building.
Safe
92
Extremely safe content. Deals with grief and social awkwardness but no mature themes, violence, or inappropriate content. Common Sense Media confirms it's appropriate for the target age. The main 'conflict' is Maddie's secret notebook being discovered—relatable middle school drama without anything shocking or triggering.
Enriching
79
Strong STEM representation with a girl protagonist who loves science and lab work. Explores grief processing, friendship dynamics, and the consequences of objectifying people versus seeing them as complex individuals. The notebook discovery creates genuine ethical questions about privacy and empathy. Solid emotional intelligence building for the age group.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
STEM girl protagonist who wants to work in her dad's research lab instead of dealing with social drama—refreshing and relatable for science-minded kids
Handles real grief (loss of grandfather) and friendship loss without being heavy-handed or overly sentimental
The notebook premise is clever: Maddie writes clinical observations about her peers, which backfires spectacularly when discovered
Teaches empathy and perspective-taking through natural consequences rather than lecturing
Strong Amazon rating (4.6/5) suggests kids actually enjoy reading it
⚠
What to Watch For
Grief is a central theme—Maddie is processing her grandfather's death throughout, though it's handled gently
Social embarrassment when the notebook is discovered might be uncomfortable for sensitive readers who've experienced similar situations
Some kids might find the pacing slow if they're expecting action over character development
Conversation Starters
"Maddie treats people like science experiments at first. Have you ever felt like you were observing people from the outside instead of really connecting?"
"What would you do if someone was writing observations about you in a secret notebook? How would that feel?"
"Maddie really misses her grandfather. What are some ways people in your life help you when you're sad or missing someone?"
"Do you think it's easier to understand science or understand people? Why?"
