Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Play

Screenwise Verdict

Sonic Mania is what happens when developers actually care about making a good game instead of a monetization machine. It's a love letter to classic Sonic that kids today can genuinely enjoy—not just nostalgia bait for parents.

The gameplay is tight, the levels are creative, and there's zero predatory nonsense. No surprise charges, no chat with strangers, no battle pass FOMO. Just a solid platformer that rewards skill and exploration.

The main consideration is difficulty. This isn't Mario's gentle learning curve—Sonic Mania expects you to learn patterns, time jumps precisely, and handle some legitimate challenge. Younger or less experienced gamers may need patience (or a helpful older sibling). But for kids ready for that challenge, it's genuinely enriching in the way good games used to be: you get better through practice, not by opening your wallet.

It's also worth noting this came out in 2017, so it's not bleeding-edge, but the retro aesthetic means it doesn't feel dated the way a 2017 realistic game might. If your kid likes platformers and can handle some challenge, this is an easy yes.

Age Fit

Best for ages 7-14, though younger kids can enjoy it with help. The skill requirement is real—this isn't a baby game—but it's accessible enough for elementary schoolers who've played other platformers. Teens who grew up with Sonic or appreciate retro gaming will still enjoy it.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

82

Classic platformer gameplay with cartoonish action against robots and Dr. Eggman. Violence is completely non-graphic (jump on robots, they poof). Cooperative mode encourages teamwork. Competition mode is friendly rivalry without toxic elements. Pacing can be fast but isn't chaotic in a concerning way—it's intentional speed-based gameplay that rewards skill.

Imaginative

78

Celebrates Sonic's legacy while adding creative twists to classic zones. Level design encourages exploration with multiple paths and hidden secrets. The 'new twist on classic zones' shows creativity in reimagining familiar content. However, it's primarily a platformer with set levels rather than open-ended creative expression like building or sandbox games. Still, the speedrunning potential and discovery elements spark problem-solving.

Safe

88

No in-game purchases, no loot boxes, no online chat. Users can interact in local multiplayer only, which keeps it contained. The game has clear boundaries and endpoints (not an infinite loop design). Violence is cartoonish robot-smashing with no blood or realistic harm. No unexpected content that would shock parents. The IGDB rating of 84/100 suggests quality without controversy. Only minor deduction for the competitive intensity that can sometimes frustrate younger players.

Enriching

68

Develops hand-eye coordination, timing, pattern recognition, and spatial reasoning. Speedrunning aspects teach perseverance and optimization. Cooperative play builds teamwork skills. However, it's primarily entertainment-focused rather than deeply educational. The skill ceiling is high, which can be enriching for dedicated players but may not offer much cognitive depth beyond reflexes and memorization. Still genuinely fun and engaging, which matters.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

No in-app purchases, no loot boxes, no online drama—just a complete game you buy once and actually own
Teaches persistence and pattern recognition as kids learn boss patterns and optimize routes through levels
Cooperative mode lets siblings play together without the toxicity of online multiplayer
Genuinely well-designed levels that reward exploration and replaying to find alternate paths
Fast-paced gameplay that's engaging without being overstimulating—the speed is intentional and skill-based

⚠

What to Watch For

The difficulty ramps up significantly—younger kids (under 7) may get frustrated with later zones and boss fights
Competition mode can lead to sibling rivalry, though it's generally good-natured compared to online competitive games
Some kids may find the retro 2D pixel art style less appealing than modern 3D games (though many love it)

Conversation Starters

"Which zone is your favorite? What makes it fun to play through?"
"When you get stuck on a boss, what strategies do you try? How do you figure out the pattern?"
"Do you like playing cooperatively with a friend or competing against them better? Why?"
"What's the coolest shortcut or secret area you've found?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic