Is the 'Plague' in the title too graphic for a 10-year-old?

Not really. It uses the historical context of the Black Death to create stakes and atmosphere, but it doesn't dwell on the gore or medical trauma. It's more of a 'looming threat' than a medical procedural.

How heavy is the romance?

It's very 'clean' YA. Think longing glances and emotional connection rather than anything physical. It’s safe for kids who aren't ready for older teen content.

Does this book stand alone or is it part of a long series?

It's a standalone novel, which is a relief for parents tired of buying 7-book box sets. It tells a complete story with a clear beginning, middle, and end.

In the best way—by accident. Your kid will learn about the layout of Florence and the life of a Renaissance artist without realizing they're absorbing 'school' facts.

Plague in the Mirror – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Plague in the Mirror

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2013

83%

WISE Score

A high-stakes Freaky Friday twist set in Renaissance Florence with time-travel, art, and a doppelganger who wants your life.

Plague in the Mirror

book

2013

83%

WISE Score

A high-stakes Freaky Friday twist set in Renaissance Florence with time-travel, art, and a doppelganger who wants your life.

Jump to

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Plague in the Mirror is a solid, imaginative pick for kids who want a mystery with some meat on its bones. It avoids the 'brain rot' tropes of modern social-media-driven YA and instead leans into art history, time travel, and a genuinely creepy identity-swap plot.

It's the kind of book that works well for a kid who just finished a series like Percy Jackson and wants something slightly more grounded in history but still featuring that 'portal to another world' energy. It’s a 2013 release, so it doesn't feel ancient, but it also lacks the frantic pacing of newer titles—which is actually a refreshing change for building a kid's attention span.

Age Fit

Perfect for the 11-14 crowd. It has enough romantic tension to satisfy middle-schoolers but keeps the 'thriller' elements grounded enough for younger readers who aren't ready for full-blown horror.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

The story centers on a summer in Florence and a romance with an artist, leaning more into historical wonder and mystery than grit. While there is a 'evil twin' threat, it's handled with typical middle-grade/YA tension rather than anything gratuitous.

Imaginative

The use of a time portal in a specific historical setting like Renaissance Florence is a fantastic imaginative hook. The doppelganger swap adds a layer of identity-driven fantasy that keeps the plot moving.

Safe

As a 2013 middle-grade/YA novel, it avoids the explicit content found in modern 'New Adult' titles. The main peril is the threat of being trapped in the past, which is suspenseful but safe for the target age.

Enriching

The Florence setting provides a rich backdrop for art history and geography. It encourages an interest in the Renaissance and the lives of historical artists without feeling like a textbook.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

The Florence setting is vibrant and serves as more than just a backdrop; it's a love letter to Italian art and history.
The doppelganger twist adds a genuine sense of urgency and mystery that keeps kids turning pages.
It's a great gateway to historical fiction for kids who think history is boring but love a good 'what if' scenario.
The clean romance subplot is handled with a sweetness that fits the younger end of the YA spectrum perfectly.

⚠

What to Watch For

The threat of identity theft and being 'erased' by a twin can be a bit existential and spooky for more sensitive readers.
The title mentions 'Plague,' so expect some grim historical realities about the 14th century to crop up as the plot thickens.

Conversation Starters

"If you met a version of yourself from 600 years ago, what's the first thing you'd ask them?"
"Would you rather live in modern-day Florence or the Renaissance version, knowing what you know about medicine and technology?"
"Why do you think May's doppelganger is so desperate to take over her modern life?"
"If you were trapped in the past, what skills do you have right now that would actually help you survive?"

Deep Dive

The Appeal of the 'Other Me'

There is a specific kind of thrill in the doppelganger trope that hits perfectly in middle school, right when kids are starting to figure out their own identities. Plague in the Mirror takes that 'who am I?' anxiety and literalizes it by having a girl from the past try to steal the protagonist's life. It’s a smart move that gives the historical setting an immediate, personal stake.

More Than a History Lesson

While the book is categorized under 'Florence (Italy),' it isn't a dry walk through the Uffizi. The inclusion of a painter love interest allows the author to discuss the creative process and the importance of art in a way that feels organic to the story. For a kid who spends their time drawing or visiting museums, this will land much harder than a standard fantasy quest.

If your kid liked the A Night-In series or even the lighter elements of The Da Vinci Code, this is a great middle-ground. It’s a self-contained story that doesn't demand a 12-book commitment, making it a low-friction choice for a summer reading list.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Plague in the Mirror? Put this WISE score on your site