Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is exactly what solid middle-grade fiction should be: a mystery that keeps kids engaged, characters worth caring about, and themes that land without lecturing. Sarah Weeks (who wrote the excellent So B. It) knows how to balance quirk with heart.
The setup is genuinely fun—a recipe left to a cat!—and the execution delivers on the promise. It's not going to change anyone's life, but it's the kind of book kids actually finish and remember fondly. The 4.6 Amazon rating and enthusiastic kid reviews back this up.
In a world of middle-grade books that try too hard to be edgy or relevant, Pie is refreshingly timeless. It's about pie, cats, small-town dynamics, and figuring out what actually matters. Sometimes that's exactly what you need.
Age Fit
Ideal for ages 8-12, the sweet spot for middle-grade readers who enjoy gentle mysteries with friendship at the center. The reading level is accessible for confident third-graders, while fifth and sixth graders will appreciate the humor and themes without feeling talked down to.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
A warm middle-grade story centered on family, friendship, and community that handles grief (Aunt Polly's death) with gentle humor. Models cooperation as Alice and Charlie work together to solve the mystery, and emphasizes doing things 'for the right reason' rather than competition or greed. The town's pie-crazy behavior provides a light comedic take on human nature without meanness.
Imaginative
76
The central conceit—leaving a recipe to a cat named Lardo—is quirky and memorable. The mystery structure invites kids to piece together clues alongside Alice. However, it's a fairly straightforward middle-grade mystery without particularly innovative storytelling or world-building that pushes creative boundaries. It's clever comfort food, not groundbreaking.
Safe
95
Exceptionally safe for its target audience. Aunt Polly's death is the inciting incident but handled in a matter-of-fact, non-traumatic way typical of middle-grade fiction. No violence, scary content, or inappropriate themes. The 'disagreeable cat' and town squabbles are played for gentle humor. Books are inherently low-risk for unexpected content.
Enriching
78
Delivers solid middle-grade lessons about friendship, family bonds, and intrinsic vs. extrinsic motivation (doing things for the right reason, not just to win). The mystery format builds problem-solving skills. Amazon rating of 4.6 and positive reader reviews suggest it resonates emotionally. Not particularly deep or challenging, but offers meaningful takeaways wrapped in an entertaining package.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Perfect middle-grade mystery with humor and heart—accessible plot that keeps kids turning pages
Models healthy friendship and cooperation through Alice and Charlie's partnership
Handles loss (Aunt Polly's death) in a gentle, age-appropriate way that opens conversations about grief
The central message about doing things 'for the right reason' vs. competition/greed is delivered without being preachy
A fat, disagreeable cat named Lardo inheriting a recipe is exactly the kind of absurdist detail kids love
⚠
What to Watch For
The story opens with a character's death—handled gently, but worth a heads-up for sensitive readers
Some town residents behave badly (greed, competitiveness) before learning their lesson—good teaching moments
Might feel a bit slow for kids who prefer action-heavy plots; this is more cozy mystery than thriller
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think Aunt Polly left the recipe to Lardo instead of a person?"
"Have you ever wanted to win something so badly that you forgot why you wanted it in the first place?"
"What do you think makes someone a good friend, like Charlie is to Alice?"
"If you could be famous for making one food, what would it be and why?"
