Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Paper Girls has a legitimately cool hook—four young friends in 1988 time-travel to 2019, meet their adult selves, and get tangled in an intergalactic war. The premise is rich for conversations about identity, choices, and who we become, plus it's refreshing to see four distinct female leads working together.

But here's the deal-breaker: Amazon cancelled it after one season, so the story just... stops. No resolution, no answers, just a cliffhanger that will never get closure. That's deeply frustrating for viewers who invest in the mystery.

Even setting that aside, the show's modest 7.3 TMDB rating and lack of buzz suggest it didn't quite stick the landing. The sci-fi action likely includes violence and peril, and the emotional complexity of meeting your future self (with all the disappointments and surprises that entails) may be heavier than families expect from a show about kid paper-delivery girls.

If you're okay with an unfinished story and have a tween who loves time-travel sci-fi, it might be worth a watch. But honestly? There are more satisfying options out there that actually, you know, end.

Age Fit

Best for tweens and teens (11-16) who can handle sci-fi action and emotionally complex themes about identity and growing up. Younger kids will likely find it confusing or intense, older teens may find it a bit juvenile.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

68

Four young friends working together and discovering their strengths models solid cooperation and friendship. The time-travel premise meeting their adult selves offers natural coming-of-age themes. However, as a sci-fi action series with intergalactic battles, expect some tension and conflict that may feel intense for younger viewers. Pacing likely leans toward action-adventure rather than calm reflection.

Imaginative

78

Time travel from 1988 to 2019 with intergalactic warfare is inherently creative and invites curiosity about different eras, identity, and consequences of choices. Meeting your adult self is a genuinely original hook that sparks questions about who we become. The sci-fi mystery blend encourages speculation and wonder, though as a passive viewing experience it doesn't invite active creation.

Safe

55

Without a formal content rating and limited data, caution is warranted. 'Intergalactic battle' and 'saving the world' suggest action violence that could include weapons, peril, and potentially scary imagery. Time-travel sci-fi often includes existential themes (meeting adult selves, changing timelines) that may be emotionally complex or unsettling for younger kids. The 1988-to-2019 jump may also include cultural references or themes (sexuality, identity, adult struggles) that could surprise families expecting a light kids' adventure. Kids Mode availability suggests Amazon considered it family-adjacent but not strictly for young children.

Enriching

70

The premise of confronting your future self is rich territory for discussions about identity, choices, growth, and who we want to become. Four distinct female protagonists discovering their strengths offers empowerment and representation. The 1988/2019 time gap can spark conversations about technology, culture, and social change. However, entertainment value may be limited by the show's cancellation after one season (leaving story unresolved) and modest TMDB rating of 7.3, suggesting it didn't fully land with audiences.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Meeting your future self is a genuinely cool premise that sparks big questions about identity and choices
Four distinct female leads discovering their strengths together—solid friendship and empowerment vibes
Time-travel from 1988 to 2019 offers natural conversations about how technology, culture, and society have changed
Sci-fi mystery blend keeps things moving and encourages speculation about what's really happening

⚠

What to Watch For

Cancelled after one season means no resolution—you're signing up for a cliffhanger that never gets answered
Intergalactic battle likely means sci-fi action violence, weapons, peril, and potentially scary imagery
Meeting adult selves may surface mature themes (identity struggles, life disappointments, sexuality) that could be emotionally heavy
Without a content rating, it's unclear exactly what you're getting into—proceed cautiously with younger viewers

Conversation Starters

"If you could meet your future self, what would you want to ask them?"
"Which of the four girls do you relate to most and why?"
"What do you think is the biggest difference between 1988 and now? What would surprise someone from back then?"
"If you could change something about your future, would you? What might go wrong if you did?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Paper Girls? Put this WISE score on your site