Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Look, this isn't the Nancy Drew of your childhood. The CW took the iconic teen detective and gave her the Riverdale treatment: dark, moody, supernatural, and packed with relationship drama.

Is it terrible? No. The mystery-solving framework is solid, and Kennedy McMann does a decent job as Nancy. But is it great? Also no. The Metacritic score of 55 tells the story—it's aggressively mediocre, trying too hard to be edgy while relying on tired CW tropes.

For teens 14+ who are into supernatural mysteries and can handle some legitimately scary moments, it's watchable entertainment. But parents should know this is horror-adjacent content with murder investigations, sexual content, and intensity that goes way beyond the classic books. And honestly? Even from 2019, it already feels dated—that peak-CW aesthetic is showing its age.

If your teen is looking for a smart female detective, there are better options. But if they're specifically into the supernatural mystery vibe and you're okay with the mature content, it'll keep them entertained for a few episodes before the formula gets repetitive.

Age Fit

Best for ages 14-17 who can handle horror elements and mature content. The Common Sense Media rating of 14+ is spot-on—younger kids will find it too scary and intense, while many adults will find the CW drama formula tiresome. This is squarely teen territory.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

55

The CW's Nancy Drew takes a darker, more mature turn than the classic books. While it models problem-solving and teamwork, the tone is moody and intense with supernatural horror elements, murders, and relationship drama that skews more angsty than emotionally healthy. The pacing can be chaotic with multiple plot threads. Not exactly wholesome family viewing.

Imaginative

68

Blending classic mystery with supernatural horror is a creative twist on the beloved character. The show invites viewers to puzzle through clues alongside Nancy, though it leans more on genre tropes (ghosts, curses) than truly original storytelling. Still, the mystery-solving framework encourages deductive thinking and curiosity.

Safe

48

This is where Nancy Drew stumbles for younger viewers. Common Sense Media rates it 14+ for good reason: supernatural violence, murder investigations with occasional graphic imagery, sexual content and innuendo, some language, and genuinely scary moments. The horror elements can be intense and unexpected. Not something you'd want a 10-year-old stumbling into.

Enriching

58

There's value in the mystery-solving, critical thinking, and female protagonist who's intelligent and driven. However, the show prioritizes CW-style drama and supernatural thrills over meaningful character development or life lessons. It's entertaining but not particularly enriching—more popcorn TV than thought-provoking content. The IMDb 6.7 and Metacritic 55 suggest it's middling quality.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Strong female lead who solves crimes using intelligence and determination rather than superpowers
Mystery-solving format encourages critical thinking and piecing together clues
Modernizes a classic character for contemporary audiences who want darker, more complex storytelling
Diverse cast and representation in a genre that's historically been very white

⚠

What to Watch For

Supernatural horror elements including ghosts, hauntings, and genuinely scary scenes—not your grandmother's Nancy Drew
Murder investigations with occasional graphic content and disturbing imagery
Mature themes: sexual content, relationship drama, and language that push beyond typical teen fare
CW-style melodrama that can get exhausting with its constant angst and relationship chaos

Conversation Starters

"What clues would you have picked up on that Nancy missed (or vice versa)?"
"How is this version of Nancy different from the books? Which do you prefer and why?"
"Do you think the supernatural elements make the mysteries more or less interesting?"
"What would you do if you discovered your hometown had dark secrets like Horseshoe Bay?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic