Nancy Drew Mystery Stories – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Nancy Drew Mystery Stories

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2015

72%

WISE Score

4.8

Amazon

The OG girl detective solves mysteries in her roadster—still charming, occasionally creaky, reliably wholesome.

Nancy Drew Mystery Stories

book

2015

72%

WISE Score

4.8

Amazon

The OG girl detective solves mysteries in her roadster—still charming, occasionally creaky, reliably wholesome.

4.8

Jump to

Also rated on

4.8

View →

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Nancy Drew is a cultural institution for good reason—she's smart, brave, and gets things done. These classic mysteries have launched countless young readers into chapter books and inspired generations of girls to be curious and confident.

That said, let's be honest: these books are showing their age. The prose is workmanlike, the formula is predictable, and you'll encounter some cringey 1950s attitudes even in revised editions. Modern kids raised on Percy Jackson or Keeper of the Lost Cities may find Nancy a bit... quaint.

But here's the thing: they still work. The mysteries are engaging enough, the reading level is perfect for that 8-10 sweet spot, and there's something genuinely delightful about a girl detective in a roadster solving crimes. If your kid is into mysteries and you want something reliably wholesome with zero screen time, Nancy Drew delivers. Just maybe prep them for the fact that some of the language and attitudes are from, like, their great-grandma's era.

Age Fit

Best for ages 8-12, which aligns with the publisher's recommendation and the reading level. Strong readers at 7 can handle them, but the protagonist is 18 and some situations may feel distant. By middle school, many kids have moved on to more complex mysteries, though Nancy Drew fans remain loyal.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Classic mystery series featuring a capable, independent teenage girl who solves problems through intelligence and determination. Models curiosity, bravery, and helping others. The original books (1930s-1950s) have some dated gender roles and occasional racial stereotypes, but the stories emphasize cooperation with friends and doing the right thing. Pacing is steady and age-appropriate for middle-grade readers.

Imaginative

Each book presents a distinct mystery puzzle that invites readers to follow clues and piece together solutions alongside Nancy. The settings vary—old clocks, hidden staircases, bungalows, inns—offering different atmospheric backdrops. However, the formula is fairly predictable and the writing style is straightforward rather than lyrical or deeply creative. Still, for the target age, these books spark curiosity and problem-solving thinking.

Safe

These are classic children's mysteries with no graphic violence, no sexual content, and no profanity. The 'danger' is mild and age-appropriate—Nancy gets into scrapes but always emerges safely. The main safety caveat is some dated attitudes (occasional stereotypes about class, race, and gender from the original era), though many editions have been revised. No unexpected trauma or shocking content. Books are inherently safe media with no ads or digital concerns.

Enriching

Nancy Drew has inspired generations of girls to be confident, curious, and independent. The books build vocabulary, encourage logical thinking and deduction, and model perseverance. However, they're entertainment-first rather than deeply educational—you won't find much character development or complex themes. The mysteries are engaging but formulaic. Still, getting kids reading chapter books and problem-solving is valuable, and Nancy remains an iconic role model.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Nancy Drew is an enduring icon of female independence and intelligence—she's been inspiring girls to be brave and curious since 1930
Each mystery offers a satisfying puzzle with clues to follow, teaching logical thinking and deduction
The books get kids reading chapter books independently, building vocabulary and reading stamina
High 4.8-star rating on Amazon shows these classics still resonate with modern families
This boxed set includes the first four books with gorgeous vintage-style covers—perfect for collectors or introducing new readers

⚠

What to Watch For

The original books reflect 1930s-1950s attitudes—some editions have been revised, but you may still encounter dated gender roles and occasional racial/class stereotypes
The mysteries follow a predictable formula: Nancy gets a case, encounters suspicious characters, gets into mild danger, solves everything neatly
The prose is straightforward and somewhat stiff by modern standards—don't expect the wit of Lemony Snicket or the emotional depth of contemporary middle-grade fiction
Some 8-year-olds may find the reading level accessible but the situations (Nancy is 18, drives, dates) not entirely relatable

Conversation Starters

"What clues did you notice that Nancy missed at first? What would you have done differently?"
"Nancy's pretty fearless—would you go into that spooky house alone, or would you bring backup?"
"How is Nancy's life different from yours? What's it like that she can just drive around solving mysteries without her dad worrying?"
"Who's your favorite character—Nancy, her friends Bess and George, or someone else? Why?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic