Mustache!

Mustache!

book

2011, Children's Books, Literature & Fiction

WISE
79%

WISE Score

4.3

Amazon

A vain king learns that a handsome face can't fix a crumbling kingdom—but a mustache might help his subjects take charge.

Amazon4.3
Common Sense Media

Where to Read

Amazon
Amazon
Barnes & Noble
Barnes & Noble
Libby
Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is a perfectly fine picture book from a very good children's author. Mac Barnett knows his craft, and 'Mustache!' delivers a clever lesson about vanity and leadership wrapped in absurdist humor that works for the preschool-to-early-elementary crowd.

It's not going to blow your mind—it's not 'Extra Yarn' or 'Sam & Dave Dig a Hole' (both Caldecott Honor winners)—but it's a solid library checkout or classroom read. The 4.3 Amazon rating and positive kid reviews on DogoBooks suggest it lands well with its target audience.

The message is useful without being heavy-handed: good looks don't make a good leader, and communities can organize when their leaders fail them. The mustache as a plot device is silly enough to keep kids engaged while the adults reading it won't want to gouge their eyes out.

Bottom line: A good book, not a great one. Worth reading if you stumble across it, but not necessarily worth hunting down unless you're collecting Barnett's entire catalog.

Age Fit

Best for ages 3-7, the sweet spot for picture books with a clear moral lesson. Preschoolers will enjoy the silly mustache premise, while early elementary kids can grasp the deeper message about leadership and vanity. By age 8+, most kids will have moved on to chapter books.

WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
82

A picture book with a positive message about substance over appearance and citizens standing up for themselves. The tone is playful and age-appropriate, with humor that doesn't rely on meanness. The king is vain but not cruel, and the solution is clever rather than violent. Models community action and the idea that good looks alone don't make a good leader.

Imaginative
78

Mac Barnett brings his signature clever storytelling to a simple premise—subjects use a mustache to teach their handsome but useless king a lesson. The concept is absurdist and whimsical (solving a kingdom crisis with facial hair), and Kevin Cornell's illustrations add visual creativity. It's not groundbreaking but it's playful and encourages kids to think about creative problem-solving and the gap between appearance and competence.

Safe
95

This is a straightforward picture book with no concerning content. No violence, scary imagery, or mature themes. The 'conflict' is that the king is vain and neglectful, but it's handled with humor and a gentle lesson. Completely appropriate for young children to read independently or have read to them.

Enriching
74

Delivers a solid lesson about vanity, leadership, and the importance of action over appearance. The story touches on civic responsibility—when leaders fail, communities can organize and respond. It's not deeply complex but offers good conversation starters about what makes a good leader and why looks don't equal competence. Mac Barnett is a skilled children's author (Caldecott Honor winner for other works), so the execution is strong. Entertaining enough to hold attention while delivering its message.

Parent Info
✓

Why It Might Be Great

  • Mac Barnett is a legitimately great children's author (multiple Caldecott Honors) who knows how to make picture books that don't bore adults
  • Teaches a useful lesson about leadership and substance over style without being preachy
  • The absurdist humor (solving a kingdom crisis with facial hair) is genuinely funny for kids
  • Short and snappy—perfect for bedtime or classroom read-alouds without overstaying its welcome
⚠

What to Watch For

  • It's a solid picture book but not one of Barnett's most celebrated works—if you love it, check out his Caldecott Honor books like 'Extra Yarn' or 'Sam & Dave Dig a Hole'
  • The lesson is pretty straightforward—older elementary kids might find it too simple
  • Published in 2011, so the illustrations have a slightly older aesthetic (though not problematically dated)

Conversation Starters

  • "Why do you think the king only cared about building statues of his face instead of helping his people?"
  • "What makes someone a good leader? Is it how they look or what they do?"
  • "Have you ever seen someone who seemed really cool or impressive but then wasn't very nice or helpful?"
  • "If you were in charge of a kingdom, what would you do to help your people?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Mustache!? Put this WISE score on your site