Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is Eric Carle doing what he does best: taking a simple nature concept and making it gorgeous and accessible for the youngest readers. The male seahorse pregnancy angle gives it a gentle progressive edge without being preachy—it's just showing kids that dads can be nurturing caregivers, which is both scientifically accurate and socially valuable.
The peek-a-boo acetate pages are the real star here, giving toddlers something interactive to do while you read. It's not groundbreaking storytelling—Mr. Seahorse literally just swims around meeting other fish dads—but for the 1-3 crowd, repetition and simplicity are features, not bugs.
It's a solid addition to any baby bookshelf, especially if you're building a collection that shows diverse family structures and involved fathers. Not quite as iconic as The Very Hungry Caterpillar, but it holds its own as a gentle, educational, beautifully illustrated board book that will survive many readings.
Age Fit
Perfect for ages 1-4, especially the board book format which can handle toddler enthusiasm. Older preschoolers (5+) might prefer the original picture book version with more detailed art, but this chunky version is ideal for lap reading with babies and young toddlers who are still exploring books with their hands and mouths.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Sweet celebration of paternal care with Mr. Seahorse carrying eggs on his belly while meeting other devoted underwater dads. Models nurturing behavior and flips traditional gender roles without being preachy. Gentle, warm tone perfect for toddlers.
Imaginative
72
Eric Carle's signature bright collage illustrations bring underwater world to life with peek-a-boo clear pages that hide and reveal sea creatures. Introduces kids to unusual animal behaviors (male seahorses, tilapia, nurseryfish caring for young). Not wildly inventive storytelling, but the interactive acetate pages and vibrant visuals spark curiosity about ocean life.
Safe
98
Board book format is baby-proof. Zero concerning content—just a dad seahorse swimming around meeting other fish dads. Educational nature facts presented gently. No scary moments, no sad parts, nothing that could upset even the most sensitive toddler.
Enriching
79
Teaches real marine biology (seahorse reproduction, camouflage, species diversity) in accessible way. Normalizes involved fatherhood and shows that caregiving isn't gendered. The peek-a-boo pages teach object permanence and prediction. Solid educational value for the 1-4 crowd, though not deeply complex.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Celebrates father involvement in a genuinely sweet way—Mr. Seahorse carries the eggs while Mrs. Seahorse swims off, and he meets other devoted fish dads along the way
Those clear peek-a-boo pages are toddler catnip—hiding and revealing camouflaged fish teaches observation skills and keeps little ones engaged
Real science woven in naturally: kids learn that male seahorses actually do carry babies, plus facts about tilapia, Kurtus nurseryfish, and other unusual parenting behaviors
Eric Carle's signature bright collage art is timeless and visually stimulating without being chaotic
Board book format means it can survive being chewed, thrown, and read 47 times in a row
⚠
What to Watch For
This is firmly toddler territory—if your kid is past the board book stage, they'll want the original picture book version with more detailed illustrations
The story is gentle and repetitive, which is perfect for babies but might bore older preschoolers who want more plot
Some kids get frustrated with the acetate pages if they're expecting to turn regular pages—just a heads up for the tactile learners
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think Mr. Seahorse carries the eggs instead of Mrs. Seahorse? Who takes care of you when you're sick or tired?"
"Can you spot the hidden fish behind the clear pages before I turn them? What colors help them hide?"
"What other dads do we know who take care of their babies? Does your dad or papa do things like Mr. Seahorse?"
"Which underwater dad was your favorite? The one with eggs in his mouth or the one carrying them on his head?"
