Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Locke & Key is that tricky show where the premise sounds like middle-grade fantasy—magical keys! sibling adventure!—but the execution is firmly teen horror. The opening scene alone (dad murdered in a home invasion) sets a dark tone that never really lifts.

The magical key system is legitimately cool and imaginative, and the mystery elements are well-crafted enough to keep teens engaged across three seasons. The sibling dynamics are strong, and there's real emotional depth in how the family processes trauma. But let's be clear: this is horror-fantasy, not whimsical fantasy. There are demons, possession, people dying, body horror, and a consistently dark atmosphere.

For parents of 14+, this could be a solid choice if your teen enjoys shows like Stranger Things or Chilling Adventures of Sabrina—it's in that horror-lite-for-teens zone. The production value is high, the story is compelling, and it does explore meaningful themes about grief and family. Just don't let the younger siblings wander in during episode one, or you'll be dealing with nightmares for weeks.

Bottom line: Know what you're getting into. This isn't Narnia with keys instead of a wardrobe. It's a teen horror show with genuine scares and dark content, wrapped in a fantasy premise.

Age Fit

Best for ages 14-17 who can handle horror elements and dark themes. The magical premise might attract younger kids, but the violence, horror, and traumatic opening make it inappropriate for anyone under 13. Upper teens might find it a bit YA-skewing but still entertaining.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

52

The show opens with the traumatic murder of the father, which becomes the emotional catalyst for the entire series. While it explores family bonds and sibling cooperation as the kids navigate grief together, the tone is dark and often tense. The horror elements and persistent threat of violence create an atmosphere that's more unsettling than emotionally healthy for younger viewers. The family dynamics are positive, but they're overshadowed by supernatural danger and psychological darkness.

Imaginative

78

The magical key system is genuinely creative—each key unlocks different powers (flying, becoming a ghost, opening portals, changing your appearance, accessing memories). The ancestral estate setting with hidden doors and secrets invites exploration and mystery-solving. The fantasy world-building is rich and the concept of keys as literal unlocking mechanisms for supernatural abilities is clever. It sparks curiosity about what other keys might exist and what they could do.

Safe

38

This is where Locke & Key struggles significantly. The series opens with a graphic home invasion and murder. It contains horror elements including demons, possession, body horror, and supernatural violence throughout. There are jump scares, psychological manipulation, characters being killed or seriously threatened, and an overall dark atmosphere. The horror and fantasy genres blend in ways that include disturbing imagery—people's heads being removed, supernatural creatures, and intense peril. While not gratuitously gory by adult horror standards, it's absolutely not safe for unexpected viewing by younger audiences. This is firmly teen territory with content that would genuinely frighten or disturb younger children.

Enriching

62

The show explores meaningful themes of grief, trauma processing, and family resilience after loss. The mystery elements require attention and problem-solving as viewers piece together clues about the keys and the family history. It touches on responsibility (the kids must protect the keys), trust, and the consequences of power. However, the enrichment is somewhat diluted by the horror elements—it's more focused on thrills and supernatural drama than deep character development or life lessons. The entertainment value is high for the target demographic, but the takeaways are moderate.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Genuinely creative magical system with keys that unlock different supernatural abilities—flying, ghost form, memory access, and more
Strong sibling dynamics as three kids work together to protect their family and solve mysteries
Explores grief and trauma processing in the aftermath of losing a parent, which could resonate with teens facing loss
Mystery elements keep you engaged as the family history and key origins slowly reveal themselves
High production value and compelling storytelling that teens who like horror-lite will devour

⚠

What to Watch For

Opens with the father's murder in a home invasion—it's the inciting incident and it's traumatic
Consistent horror elements: demons, possession, people getting hurt or killed, jump scares, and body horror
Dark psychological themes that might be heavy for sensitive teens or anyone processing real trauma
The 'safe for kids' vibe of magical keys is misleading—this is absolutely teen horror territory
Binge-worthy format might mean staying up too late or getting genuinely scared before bed

Conversation Starters

"If you could have one magical key, which power would you want and how would you use it responsibly?"
"The kids have to keep the keys secret from most adults. When do you think it's okay to keep secrets from parents, and when is it dangerous?"
"How do you think each sibling is dealing with their dad's death differently? Is there a 'right' way to grieve?"
"The show is about literal keys unlocking things. What do you think you're still 'locked out of' understanding about yourself or the world?"
"Would you trust your siblings with this kind of power and responsibility? Why or why not?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic